But they make some pretty good points, including:
"The longer the campaign goes on, the more the issues of personality and character have reflected badly on McCain. Unless appearances are very deceiving, he is impulsive, impatient, self-dramatizing, erratic, and a compulsive risk-taker. These qualities may have contributed to his usefulness as a “maverick” senator. But in a President they would be a menace.
By contrast, Obama’s transformative message is accompanied by a sense of pragmatic calm. A tropism for unity is an essential part of his character and of his campaign. It is part of what allowed him to overcome a Democratic opponent who entered the race with tremendous advantages. It is what helped him forge a political career relying both on the liberals of Hyde Park and on the political regulars of downtown Chicago. His policy preferences are distinctly liberal, but he is determined to speak to a broad range of Americans who do not necessarily share his every value or opinion. For some who oppose him, his equanimity even under the ugliest attack seems like hauteur; for some who support him, his reluctance to counterattack in the same vein seems like self-defeating detachment. Yet it is Obama’s temperament—and not McCain’s—that seems appropriate for the office both men seek and for the volatile and dangerous era in which we live. Those who dismiss his centeredness as self-centeredness or his composure as indifference are as wrong as those who mistook Eisenhower’s stolidity for denseness or Lincoln’s humor for lack of seriousness."
Monday, October 06, 2008
Friday, October 03, 2008
Is the McCain campaign conceding that their claims on the Bridge to Nowhere were lies?
I was just thinking about last night's debate, and it struck me that Palin dropped two of her signature claims to fame. The assertion that she said "no thanks" to the Bridge to Nowhere, and her anecdote about putting the state plane on eBay.
What gives? Were they perhaps concerned that Joe Biden might point out that the Bridge to Nowhere story is a complete lie, or that the eBay story is a huge piece of puffery?
Maybe they hope that no one noticed. I do think that if Palin begins making either two claims again someone should ask her why she was silent on these topics at the debate, or maybe just why she's lying. But of course, that would mean taking questions from a reporter, and that's something that Palin just doesn't do very often.
What gives? Were they perhaps concerned that Joe Biden might point out that the Bridge to Nowhere story is a complete lie, or that the eBay story is a huge piece of puffery?
Maybe they hope that no one noticed. I do think that if Palin begins making either two claims again someone should ask her why she was silent on these topics at the debate, or maybe just why she's lying. But of course, that would mean taking questions from a reporter, and that's something that Palin just doesn't do very often.
Thursday, October 02, 2008
VEEP debate
I don't think too many people will think Sarah Palin won the debate.
She did OK. I saw a lot of flat lines on the "voter dial," and that fit with my response. A lot of her answers kind of meandered around and didn't go anywhere. My opinion of course.
Biden was good, very good in a couple of places. I think there were a lot of landmines for him and he seemed to avoid them. But there was no Lloyd Bentsen moment where he just put the thing away. That's OK, probably not a good plan to try to hit a home run; just be steady and substantial. He was.
As a bottom line thing, I just can't see Sarah Palin as President. We've already had a folksy, chirpy, incurious idealogue who appeals to the Republican base. As has been said in comments, there's not politician that Palin recalls more than GWB. Maybe others see it differently, but I have had enough of that formula. (There's also been some comparison of her to Michelle Bachmann. Palin/Bachmann in 2012!)
I also like that Biden didn't cede any ground on Joe Sixpack or as a parent. Maybe the best part of the debate.
Palin's had two pretty good nights. The convention speech, and this debate. She prepared several days for one, at least a week for the other. Can she think at all on her feet? Can she handle a press conference? Can she really do what every other candidate has to do, go out and be held accountable by the press? We still don't know. The results that we have seen have been very mixed.
She did OK. I saw a lot of flat lines on the "voter dial," and that fit with my response. A lot of her answers kind of meandered around and didn't go anywhere. My opinion of course.
Biden was good, very good in a couple of places. I think there were a lot of landmines for him and he seemed to avoid them. But there was no Lloyd Bentsen moment where he just put the thing away. That's OK, probably not a good plan to try to hit a home run; just be steady and substantial. He was.
As a bottom line thing, I just can't see Sarah Palin as President. We've already had a folksy, chirpy, incurious idealogue who appeals to the Republican base. As has been said in comments, there's not politician that Palin recalls more than GWB. Maybe others see it differently, but I have had enough of that formula. (There's also been some comparison of her to Michelle Bachmann. Palin/Bachmann in 2012!)
I also like that Biden didn't cede any ground on Joe Sixpack or as a parent. Maybe the best part of the debate.
Palin's had two pretty good nights. The convention speech, and this debate. She prepared several days for one, at least a week for the other. Can she think at all on her feet? Can she handle a press conference? Can she really do what every other candidate has to do, go out and be held accountable by the press? We still don't know. The results that we have seen have been very mixed.
Wednesday, October 01, 2008
The Palin/Biden Debate
This will be a pretty huge night in the presidential campaign. Since the initial debate between Obama and McCain, Obama has jumped ahead in the polls by a significant margin. We’ve also seen polls showing Obama leading (by as much as 8 points) in states like Florida, Ohio, and Pennsylvania. If Obama wins Florida on Election Night, he wins this by a landslide.
There’s plenty of time to go yet, but Obama’s position has never been stronger.
So the vice presidential debate, coming on the heels of some pretty bad press for Palin, is going to be huge. Palin’s pick has been unusually high-profile, which is exactly what McCain has hoping for. It was the campaign’s biggest gamble (so far), a high-risk, high-reward proposition. After the convention, it looked like high reward. Things have changed since then.
I expect one of two outcomes: Palin does reasonably well, holds her own, doesn’t seem overwhelmed. There’s also the possibility of a Biden gaffe; he has already said some pretty dumb things on the trail. If that’s the case, if Palin’s performance is seen as a draw or better, the media will explode with “Palin outperformed expectations!” And the doubts about McCain’s VP decision will recede. It could happen. And it could bump McCain’s numbers up a bit and make this a tight race again.
Or she could perform as she has in recent interviews and really look bad. In which case, I would expect the race to break wide open. McCain is vulnerable right now. A poor performance by his pick for VP could solidify opinion that the McCain/Palin ticket is just not the answer this year.
There’s plenty of time to go yet, but Obama’s position has never been stronger.
So the vice presidential debate, coming on the heels of some pretty bad press for Palin, is going to be huge. Palin’s pick has been unusually high-profile, which is exactly what McCain has hoping for. It was the campaign’s biggest gamble (so far), a high-risk, high-reward proposition. After the convention, it looked like high reward. Things have changed since then.
I expect one of two outcomes: Palin does reasonably well, holds her own, doesn’t seem overwhelmed. There’s also the possibility of a Biden gaffe; he has already said some pretty dumb things on the trail. If that’s the case, if Palin’s performance is seen as a draw or better, the media will explode with “Palin outperformed expectations!” And the doubts about McCain’s VP decision will recede. It could happen. And it could bump McCain’s numbers up a bit and make this a tight race again.
Or she could perform as she has in recent interviews and really look bad. In which case, I would expect the race to break wide open. McCain is vulnerable right now. A poor performance by his pick for VP could solidify opinion that the McCain/Palin ticket is just not the answer this year.
Tuesday, September 30, 2008
GOP: One Party, Many Voices.
Does anyone know what the GOP stands for these days? We have a presidential candidate being contradicted by his VP candidate on the issue of military action in Pakistan. We have the GOP President pulling out all the stops to pass the bailout bill, only to be defeated by a rebellion of House Republicans. We have McCain calling for the passage of the bailout bill, only to see the Republican National Committee release a campaign ad attacking the bailout bill.
Isn’t it usually the Dems who are seen as the party of chaos? Have the two parties switched identities?
Isn’t it usually the Dems who are seen as the party of chaos? Have the two parties switched identities?
It’s Just A Complicated Game
I’ve been mostly silent on the financial bailout plan because mostly, I don’t understand it. And usually, when you’re ignorant about something, it’s better not to broadcast that fact.
However, as with most political blogs, displaying my ignorance is pretty much what I do here at the World’s Most Dangerous Political Blog ™. So here we go!
I’ve always thought of high finance as a big shell game, a kind of semi-religious con that is basically moving lots of numbers around to the benefit of those who pretend to know what the numbers mean. And when I hear, as I have constantly in the past week, that nobody really understands exactly what’s going on, or that the $700 billion number was pulled out of Henry Paulson’s Fannie Mae, or that no one is exactly sure that the bailout will really work, it makes me think that my—admittedly cynical—take might be right.
But let’s assume that a bailout really is needed. Enough smart people are saying that that I am willing to accept the premise.
The problem that faces us is, apparently, that the majority of Americans are, like me, very dubious about this fix. And in an election year, a lot of congress people are just not willing to go against their constituents and vote for this unpopular bill.
It seems to me that some sort of compromise could be found. Say, a bill that provides some security blanket to Wall Street, that doesn’t lock in another huge debt to the taxpayer, that doesn’t give too much authority to Paulsen, that basically says – “here’s what’s needed to tide us over ‘till after the election” —when the new President and Congress came take this on in a less panicked, politically-charged atmosphere.
Now, that may be kicking the can down the road, and maybe we don’t have that luxury. I simply don’t know.
What I do know is that neither of the two candidates seem to be willing to go very far in suggesting fixes, which, given the calendar, is not surprising. It’s annoying to see McCain flailing around on this, but to be honest, I’m not impressed with Obama’s kind of hands-off approach either.
I know he’s put forward a few suggestions. But mostly, I think he’s content to bash McCain and Republican mismanagement. It’s probably good politics. I personally would like to get beyond that, but I’m not always realistic about these things.
I would now like to formally apologize for wasting three-and-a-half minutes of your time.
Carry on.
However, as with most political blogs, displaying my ignorance is pretty much what I do here at the World’s Most Dangerous Political Blog ™. So here we go!
I’ve always thought of high finance as a big shell game, a kind of semi-religious con that is basically moving lots of numbers around to the benefit of those who pretend to know what the numbers mean. And when I hear, as I have constantly in the past week, that nobody really understands exactly what’s going on, or that the $700 billion number was pulled out of Henry Paulson’s Fannie Mae, or that no one is exactly sure that the bailout will really work, it makes me think that my—admittedly cynical—take might be right.
But let’s assume that a bailout really is needed. Enough smart people are saying that that I am willing to accept the premise.
The problem that faces us is, apparently, that the majority of Americans are, like me, very dubious about this fix. And in an election year, a lot of congress people are just not willing to go against their constituents and vote for this unpopular bill.
It seems to me that some sort of compromise could be found. Say, a bill that provides some security blanket to Wall Street, that doesn’t lock in another huge debt to the taxpayer, that doesn’t give too much authority to Paulsen, that basically says – “here’s what’s needed to tide us over ‘till after the election” —when the new President and Congress came take this on in a less panicked, politically-charged atmosphere.
Now, that may be kicking the can down the road, and maybe we don’t have that luxury. I simply don’t know.
What I do know is that neither of the two candidates seem to be willing to go very far in suggesting fixes, which, given the calendar, is not surprising. It’s annoying to see McCain flailing around on this, but to be honest, I’m not impressed with Obama’s kind of hands-off approach either.
I know he’s put forward a few suggestions. But mostly, I think he’s content to bash McCain and Republican mismanagement. It’s probably good politics. I personally would like to get beyond that, but I’m not always realistic about these things.
I would now like to formally apologize for wasting three-and-a-half minutes of your time.
Carry on.
Friday, September 26, 2008
What did you think?
We watched most of the debate after getting back from the ER, our son had some weird stomache pains but seems ok now. So anyhow, a little family trauma made the debate just a little less important for me.
But now that things have settled down and I've seen some of the response by the cable talkers, I would say Obama has come out of the first debate better than I expected. My wife and I both thought McCain had a very strong performance, and considering how erratic McCain has been acting recently, he seemed pretty prepared and calm.
But both candidates appeared to hold their own, and the conventional wisdom seemed to be that McCain needed a knockout to change the dynamic of the race. Of course, conventional wisdom can be wrong. We'll see in the next couple of days.
I've noticed in comments on some of the political blogs this curious claim that Obama doesn't do well in unscripted events; that he needs a prepared speech or a teleprompter. It's a ridiculous claim, yet I've seen it quite a few times. I think tonight's debate is a pretty clear refutation of that. Although the folks that make these kinds of claims always seem pretty impervious to things like evidence and logic.
Anyhow, on to the vice presidential debates!
But now that things have settled down and I've seen some of the response by the cable talkers, I would say Obama has come out of the first debate better than I expected. My wife and I both thought McCain had a very strong performance, and considering how erratic McCain has been acting recently, he seemed pretty prepared and calm.
But both candidates appeared to hold their own, and the conventional wisdom seemed to be that McCain needed a knockout to change the dynamic of the race. Of course, conventional wisdom can be wrong. We'll see in the next couple of days.
I've noticed in comments on some of the political blogs this curious claim that Obama doesn't do well in unscripted events; that he needs a prepared speech or a teleprompter. It's a ridiculous claim, yet I've seen it quite a few times. I think tonight's debate is a pretty clear refutation of that. Although the folks that make these kinds of claims always seem pretty impervious to things like evidence and logic.
Anyhow, on to the vice presidential debates!
Thursday, September 25, 2008
I'm Suspending My Blog! We'll Do it Live!
I've been wanting to post something but every time I fire up the computing machine, John McCain does something even more maverick-y and I just don't know what to say. He sure would be an exciting president.
Oh, and if you get a chance to see Palin being interviewed by Couric, well, I hope you're sitting down. Mega-maverickosity, is what I call it.
Oh, and if you get a chance to see Palin being interviewed by Couric, well, I hope you're sitting down. Mega-maverickosity, is what I call it.
Wednesday, September 24, 2008
Monday, September 22, 2008
They called it
Remember, months ago, when Hillary Clinton ran some ads that Obama supporters took issue with? Remember the “3 AM phone call” ad? Remember how the two sides argued about whether Clinton was being too unfair or misleading? And how the Clinton supporters all said, “If you think this is bad, wait until you see the Republican ads in the fall. They’ll make this look like child’s play.”
Those people didn’t prevail as far as getting their candidate nominated. But their prediction looks pretty smart, doesn’t it?
I’ve done my share of bashing the McCain campaign; I think a lot of people recognize now that his ads are over the line even for modern partisan politics. And I think, or at least hope, that people are starting to tune them out. Certainly the popular culture is beginning to get the fact that McCain will say anything to win.
Those people didn’t prevail as far as getting their candidate nominated. But their prediction looks pretty smart, doesn’t it?
I’ve done my share of bashing the McCain campaign; I think a lot of people recognize now that his ads are over the line even for modern partisan politics. And I think, or at least hope, that people are starting to tune them out. Certainly the popular culture is beginning to get the fact that McCain will say anything to win.
Housekeeping
Just a couple minor changes. I've posted some links to some factchecking sites and Pollster.com. I find these sites useful, you might too. Also, I've opened up comments so that people can leave anonymous comments. I frankly didn't realize that my settings required people to sign up to Blogger to comment. So that's changed for now. If we start getting a lot of spam or Ron Paul supporters showing up in the comments, I may put some mild restrictions up.
Thursday, September 18, 2008
Hiding Sarah
Well, here’s some very telling information about Sarah Palin’s first town-hall meeting as VP candidate, where she for the first time took questions from the public:
“The McCain campaign confirms that tonight’s event was advertised on the McCain/Palin Web site and local newspapers. People had to pick up their tickets at local GOP offices after RSVPing for the event. The Kent County GOP headquarters gave out about two thousand tickets. The rest came from GOP offices in Ottowa and Kalamazoo.”
Oh good, a hand-picked audience. You know who else regularly pulls this kind of crap? Our current president, who can talk real tough about terrorists and evildoers, but apparently can’t appear in front of people who might disagree with him. Whose widely-reported unwillingness to hear different viewpoints is credited with disasters in Iraq and here at home. Whose popularity rating hovers between 20 and 30 percent.
Great role model, McCain campaign. You go ahead with that plan and see how it works for you. Keep sending your candidates to friendly crowds in pro-Republican communities. Limit the interviews to a bare minimum, and when you do take questions, insist on interviewers like Sean Hannity or Bill O’Reilly.
There’s a basic truth to campaigning. You can run, but you can’t hide. The very fact that the McCain campaign keeps Palin away from the tough questions speaks volumes about her readiness for the Vice Presidency, and about their confidence in their pick.
The American people are starting to pay attention to this race. And they can see when one side is avoiding scrutiny. If McCain wants to turn this into a classic Rovian presidential race, where each side turns out their base, I think he’s in for a disappointment. Democratic registration is way up, Republican registration is down. It’s true Palin will bring out the hard-right evangelical base, but this year, I don’t think that’s going to be enough.
(update) ... and because it's not worth a new post but is worth reading, here's the best argument yet against Sarah Palin as VP -- from conservative pundit David Brooks.
“The McCain campaign confirms that tonight’s event was advertised on the McCain/Palin Web site and local newspapers. People had to pick up their tickets at local GOP offices after RSVPing for the event. The Kent County GOP headquarters gave out about two thousand tickets. The rest came from GOP offices in Ottowa and Kalamazoo.”
Oh good, a hand-picked audience. You know who else regularly pulls this kind of crap? Our current president, who can talk real tough about terrorists and evildoers, but apparently can’t appear in front of people who might disagree with him. Whose widely-reported unwillingness to hear different viewpoints is credited with disasters in Iraq and here at home. Whose popularity rating hovers between 20 and 30 percent.
Great role model, McCain campaign. You go ahead with that plan and see how it works for you. Keep sending your candidates to friendly crowds in pro-Republican communities. Limit the interviews to a bare minimum, and when you do take questions, insist on interviewers like Sean Hannity or Bill O’Reilly.
There’s a basic truth to campaigning. You can run, but you can’t hide. The very fact that the McCain campaign keeps Palin away from the tough questions speaks volumes about her readiness for the Vice Presidency, and about their confidence in their pick.
The American people are starting to pay attention to this race. And they can see when one side is avoiding scrutiny. If McCain wants to turn this into a classic Rovian presidential race, where each side turns out their base, I think he’s in for a disappointment. Democratic registration is way up, Republican registration is down. It’s true Palin will bring out the hard-right evangelical base, but this year, I don’t think that’s going to be enough.
(update) ... and because it's not worth a new post but is worth reading, here's the best argument yet against Sarah Palin as VP -- from conservative pundit David Brooks.
Tuesday, September 16, 2008
Resuming our regular programming
Well, I took a couple days off for camping and some family activities. It rained, of course.
But I haven’t gotten back to the World’s Most Dangerous Political Blog™ until just now. What, you don’t like my new slogan?
Seriously, it’s been an interesting few days. We’re seeing the McCain post-convention bump slowly dissipate in the polls. This may or may not continue, but I suspect that Obama will be leading most national polls by this time next week as people realize that John McCain is still at the top of the ticket and Sarah Palin is not the second coming of Reagan.
The financial crisis now gripping Wall Street is a prime opportunity for Obama to seize control of the national debate and show that he is the candidate best suited to deal with domestic issues such as this. The question is, will he? The Obama camp has shown a tendency to play it safe, keep things slow and steady. It’s easy to second-guess that strategy, but it’s been working pretty well for them, the recent setback in the polls notwithstanding. However, I wonder why they’re not grabbing this opportunity.
Maybe there are no quick fixes to the troubled financial sector. Maybe it would be irresponsible to come up with some dramatic plan for change.
All I know is that Obama is hitting McCain hard for saying that the fundamentals of our economy are sound. If they aren’t, what’s Obama’s solution? Can he articulate his vision for change in a way that we, the unwashed masses who don’t understand how Wall Street works, can understand?
He says he’s the real candidate for change. OK, so how do we fix this particular problem?
But I haven’t gotten back to the World’s Most Dangerous Political Blog™ until just now. What, you don’t like my new slogan?
Seriously, it’s been an interesting few days. We’re seeing the McCain post-convention bump slowly dissipate in the polls. This may or may not continue, but I suspect that Obama will be leading most national polls by this time next week as people realize that John McCain is still at the top of the ticket and Sarah Palin is not the second coming of Reagan.
The financial crisis now gripping Wall Street is a prime opportunity for Obama to seize control of the national debate and show that he is the candidate best suited to deal with domestic issues such as this. The question is, will he? The Obama camp has shown a tendency to play it safe, keep things slow and steady. It’s easy to second-guess that strategy, but it’s been working pretty well for them, the recent setback in the polls notwithstanding. However, I wonder why they’re not grabbing this opportunity.
Maybe there are no quick fixes to the troubled financial sector. Maybe it would be irresponsible to come up with some dramatic plan for change.
All I know is that Obama is hitting McCain hard for saying that the fundamentals of our economy are sound. If they aren’t, what’s Obama’s solution? Can he articulate his vision for change in a way that we, the unwashed masses who don’t understand how Wall Street works, can understand?
He says he’s the real candidate for change. OK, so how do we fix this particular problem?
Tuesday, September 09, 2008
Is this election about Sarah Palin?
It’s a question that has been on my mind. I know that the conservatives are excited about the pick, and with good reason. And I know Dems are a little freaked out about the bounce in the polls for McCain that seems directly attributable to Palin.
But this election is not primarily about her. It’s fine to examine her record and question her qualifications, that’s the same kind of scrutiny that every candidate has to go through. And the more resistance that the McCain team shows (and they’ve been making quite an effort to keep Palin from facing tough questions) the less good it looks.
My hope is that we can get back to discussing the two main candidates, McCain and Obama, and their strengths and weaknesses. This is pretty important election. I think a major question is whether we want to change the course this country has taken over the last 8 years. We need to focus on that, not Sarah-cudda. (That’s what they called her in Alaska, apparently.)
But if we must have another Palin post, here’s an amusing video that’s made the rounds lately.
But this election is not primarily about her. It’s fine to examine her record and question her qualifications, that’s the same kind of scrutiny that every candidate has to go through. And the more resistance that the McCain team shows (and they’ve been making quite an effort to keep Palin from facing tough questions) the less good it looks.
My hope is that we can get back to discussing the two main candidates, McCain and Obama, and their strengths and weaknesses. This is pretty important election. I think a major question is whether we want to change the course this country has taken over the last 8 years. We need to focus on that, not Sarah-cudda. (That’s what they called her in Alaska, apparently.)
But if we must have another Palin post, here’s an amusing video that’s made the rounds lately.
Sunday, September 07, 2008
Contrasting Candidates, Contrasting Conventions
The conventions are quickly becoming old news. But I wanted to mention how different Denver and St. Paul were, in terms of execution and competence.
The Dem convention came in with a lot of questions. Mostly about whether the party could come together, re: the Hillary and Obama camps. But every day, it seemed the convention kind of raised the bar. Hillary's speech went great. Bill, who the pundits seem to think would blow a gasket or something, also got rave reviews. And Obama's stadium speech, which was increasingly seen as risky by the media, also was a big success. Even the silly "Greek Temple" issue that critics whipped up about the speech's background was defused once you saw the stage itself; there was nothing unusual about it at all. In sum, the convention went pretty much like clockwork.
Compare it to the Republican convention. The hurricane, of course, was something the the R planners couldn't have predicted and couldn't control. But that problem faded quickly. Hurricane aside, the week got off to a chaotic beginning, as a total unknown was announced as VP just prior to the convention. Rudy Giuliani's speech went long, causing the convention to cancel the Palin introductory video (it was played the next night). There was the strange video background for McCain's speech. I have to say, I was absolutely astounded to see a lime green background behind McCain early in the speech, since he had been so widly ridiculed for the green screen background of an earlier speech. And the wider shot was of what appeared to be a mansion -- again, not a good image for McCain, since the "7 Houses" issue came up.
But it wasn't a mansion, turns out. It was Walter Reed Middle School in Los Angeles. Many have speculated that the McCain camp intended to put Walter Reed military hospital in the background, which would have been fitting to some degree, given McCain's past. No one knows exactly what was going on (McCain's camp, in the best Bush tradition, is refusing comment), but the bottom line is that for a huge section of thespeech, what TV viewers mostly saw was a weird green background, which was later replaced by an equally eye-damaging blue background.
That's not to say there weren't good moments to the convention. Palin's speech was a huge success. McCain had some good moments toward the end of his speech. Thompson got his baritone on.
But overall, the R convention was more chaotic, more glitchy, less disciplined. It's a small thing, I suppose. But both conventions can be seen as reflections of the management styles and basic competence of the candidates. Take your pick.
The Dem convention came in with a lot of questions. Mostly about whether the party could come together, re: the Hillary and Obama camps. But every day, it seemed the convention kind of raised the bar. Hillary's speech went great. Bill, who the pundits seem to think would blow a gasket or something, also got rave reviews. And Obama's stadium speech, which was increasingly seen as risky by the media, also was a big success. Even the silly "Greek Temple" issue that critics whipped up about the speech's background was defused once you saw the stage itself; there was nothing unusual about it at all. In sum, the convention went pretty much like clockwork.
Compare it to the Republican convention. The hurricane, of course, was something the the R planners couldn't have predicted and couldn't control. But that problem faded quickly. Hurricane aside, the week got off to a chaotic beginning, as a total unknown was announced as VP just prior to the convention. Rudy Giuliani's speech went long, causing the convention to cancel the Palin introductory video (it was played the next night). There was the strange video background for McCain's speech. I have to say, I was absolutely astounded to see a lime green background behind McCain early in the speech, since he had been so widly ridiculed for the green screen background of an earlier speech. And the wider shot was of what appeared to be a mansion -- again, not a good image for McCain, since the "7 Houses" issue came up.
But it wasn't a mansion, turns out. It was Walter Reed Middle School in Los Angeles. Many have speculated that the McCain camp intended to put Walter Reed military hospital in the background, which would have been fitting to some degree, given McCain's past. No one knows exactly what was going on (McCain's camp, in the best Bush tradition, is refusing comment), but the bottom line is that for a huge section of thespeech, what TV viewers mostly saw was a weird green background, which was later replaced by an equally eye-damaging blue background.
That's not to say there weren't good moments to the convention. Palin's speech was a huge success. McCain had some good moments toward the end of his speech. Thompson got his baritone on.
But overall, the R convention was more chaotic, more glitchy, less disciplined. It's a small thing, I suppose. But both conventions can be seen as reflections of the management styles and basic competence of the candidates. Take your pick.
Friday, September 05, 2008
The McCain Speech
You could tell John McCain was trying to appeal to a wider range of voters than his base last night. It was kind of a revival of the old John McCain, after a month of the Sneer N’ Smear campaign that his Rovian advisors have had him running.
So it was kind of nice to see the old McCain. And it was riveting to hear him talk about his POW experience. That was by far the strongest part of what was really a pretty weak speech overall.
But the POW camp was a long time ago. And the Independent Maverick Guy seems a long time ago too. John McCain may still be the patriot with his character forged by the most unimaginable hardship. But he’s also the guy who’s been lying to us for most of this campaign, and questioning Obama’s patriotism, and putting up those despicable “celebrity” ads.
He has to own all of it. The embrace of the far right. His flip-flop on taxes. His 100 Years of Occupation in Iraq. His buy-in to Bush economic policies. His hotheaded neo-con foreign policy. The rash, rushed selection of Sarah Palin, which is a brilliant short-term move but actually is appallingly risky for the country in the long run.
Judge the man as a whole. And hope that he enjoyed the night. His nomination is a fitting end to a long and admirable career. But John McCain is all about the past, not the future.
So it was kind of nice to see the old McCain. And it was riveting to hear him talk about his POW experience. That was by far the strongest part of what was really a pretty weak speech overall.
But the POW camp was a long time ago. And the Independent Maverick Guy seems a long time ago too. John McCain may still be the patriot with his character forged by the most unimaginable hardship. But he’s also the guy who’s been lying to us for most of this campaign, and questioning Obama’s patriotism, and putting up those despicable “celebrity” ads.
He has to own all of it. The embrace of the far right. His flip-flop on taxes. His 100 Years of Occupation in Iraq. His buy-in to Bush economic policies. His hotheaded neo-con foreign policy. The rash, rushed selection of Sarah Palin, which is a brilliant short-term move but actually is appallingly risky for the country in the long run.
Judge the man as a whole. And hope that he enjoyed the night. His nomination is a fitting end to a long and admirable career. But John McCain is all about the past, not the future.
Thursday, September 04, 2008
Life in a box
Geez, I guess the "McCain doesn't exploit his POW years for political purpose" myth is totally dead, right?
update: I wrote the above before McCain took the stage, when the repetitive telling of his POW story seemed a bit excessive.
But in his speech, his story of being a POW was by far the most compelling part. It's a gripping story, and as I've said before, he's a great American. But as a certain conservative pundit suggested recently, this isn't merely a personal narrative contest. This is about the future of the country, and who is best equiped to lead us.
I'll probably have some more comments on the speech later.
update: I wrote the above before McCain took the stage, when the repetitive telling of his POW story seemed a bit excessive.
But in his speech, his story of being a POW was by far the most compelling part. It's a gripping story, and as I've said before, he's a great American. But as a certain conservative pundit suggested recently, this isn't merely a personal narrative contest. This is about the future of the country, and who is best equiped to lead us.
I'll probably have some more comments on the speech later.
Just to follow up ...
From today's Washington Post:
"Only 36 of the 2,380 delegates seated on the convention floor are black, the lowest number since the Joint Center for Political and Economic Studies began tracking diversity at political conventions 40 years ago. Each night, the overwhelmingly white audience watches a series of white politicians step to the lectern -- a visual reminder that no black Republican has served as a governor, U.S. senator or U.S. House member in the past six years.
"It's hard to look around and not get frustrated," said Michael S. Steele, a black Republican and former lieutenant governor of Maryland. "You almost have to think, 'Wait. How did it come to this?' "
A few names come to mind. Ronald Reagan. Richard Nixon. Rush Limbaugh.
Not champions of diversity. And whether or not you agree that diversity is a strength of this country, not something to be feared, the fact is that diversity is our future.
Again, this kind of issue, not mooseburgers, is what this election should be about, in my opinion.
"Only 36 of the 2,380 delegates seated on the convention floor are black, the lowest number since the Joint Center for Political and Economic Studies began tracking diversity at political conventions 40 years ago. Each night, the overwhelmingly white audience watches a series of white politicians step to the lectern -- a visual reminder that no black Republican has served as a governor, U.S. senator or U.S. House member in the past six years.
"It's hard to look around and not get frustrated," said Michael S. Steele, a black Republican and former lieutenant governor of Maryland. "You almost have to think, 'Wait. How did it come to this?' "
A few names come to mind. Ronald Reagan. Richard Nixon. Rush Limbaugh.
Not champions of diversity. And whether or not you agree that diversity is a strength of this country, not something to be feared, the fact is that diversity is our future.
Again, this kind of issue, not mooseburgers, is what this election should be about, in my opinion.
Beyond the Palin Speech
(I just can’t help myself.)
So hey, good speech. After three days locked away with the best speechwriting talent that Republican money can buy, with a crowd primed and ready to cheer her on, Sarah Palin succeeded … maybe not surprisingly, but admirably.
I didn’t watch the whole speech, I’ll admit. My wife and I have been watching Buffy the Vampire Slayer on DVD lately, so we switched between butt-kickin’ heroines. And I don’t have a problem with saying Palin kicked a little butt last night. She had a great line about Obama’s foolish “bitter” comment. She had a slightly less great line about community organizers—actually pretty snide and unfair, but the crowd Luuuved it. And she got in a dig at Michelle Obama by saying how small town Americans “always” are proud of their country.
OK, so we know from this speech that she can attack the Obamas and media. And we know that John McCain is a great man. What else ya got?
At some point the R ticket really has to answer with something beside “Obama stinks.” They have to talk about the economy, about health care, about home foreclosures. They have to address education and energy—something beyond “we’ve got plenty of oil and gas on the North Range”—which, environmental concerns aside, simply isn’t true.
As they noted last night, great speeches aren’t enough. Vision is also required. And Sarah Palin’s Christianist, anti-choice, social Darwinist, anti-science vision of America is not a vision of this country’s future. It’s a vision of the past.
Speaking of a vision of the past, it was hard not to notice the Unbearable Whiteness of Being Republican last night when the cameras panned around the convention center. I mean, I expect to see fewer minorities at the RNC, but come on. I could count the number of African Americans I saw on one hand.
Now, how should the Obama camp respond to Palin’s speech? I’m thinking: the less said, the better. Let the R’s have their moment. Don’t come down like a ton of bricks on Palin and make her an even more sympathetic figure. Let McCain’s public nap, I mean, speech tonight pop the balloon all by itself. Or, if by chance he actually can match Palin (pretty unlikely, don’t you think?), give a lot of attention to the media’s fact checking.
For Palin,
it wasn’t pretty:
PALIN: "I have protected the taxpayers by vetoing wasteful spending ... and championed reform to end the abuses of earmark spending by Congress. I told the Congress 'thanks but no thanks' for that Bridge to Nowhere."
THE FACTS: As mayor of Wasilla, Palin hired a lobbyist and traveled to Washington annually to support earmarks for the town totaling $27 million. In her two years as governor, Alaska has requested nearly $750 million in special federal spending, by far the largest per-capita request in the nation. While Palin notes she rejected plans to build a $398 million bridge from Ketchikan to an island with 50 residents and an airport, that opposition came only after the plan was ridiculed nationally as a "bridge to nowhere."
PALIN: "There is much to like and admire about our opponent. But listening to him speak, it's easy to forget that this is a man who has authored two memoirs but not a single major law or reform — not even in the state senate."
THE FACTS: Compared to McCain and his two decades in the Senate, Obama does have a more meager record. But he has worked with Republicans to pass legislation that expanded efforts to intercept illegal shipments of weapons of mass destruction and to help destroy conventional weapons stockpiles. The legislation became law last year. To demean that accomplishment would be to also demean the work of Republican Sen. Richard Lugar of Indiana, a respected foreign policy voice in the Senate. In Illinois, he was the leader on two big, contentious measures in Illinois: studying racial profiling by police and requiring recordings of interrogations in potential death penalty cases. He also successfully co-sponsored major ethics reform legislation.
PALIN: "The Democratic nominee for president supports plans to raise income taxes, raise payroll taxes, raise investment income taxes, raise the death tax, raise business taxes, and increase the tax burden on the American people by hundreds of billions of dollars."
THE FACTS: The Tax Policy Center, a think tank run jointly by the Brookings Institution and the Urban Institute, concluded that Obama's plan would increase after-tax income for middle-income taxpayers by about 5 percent by 2012, or nearly $2,200 annually. McCain's plan, which cuts taxes across all income levels, would raise after tax-income for middle-income taxpayers by 3 percent, the center concluded.
(see the AP story for much more.)
So hey, good speech. After three days locked away with the best speechwriting talent that Republican money can buy, with a crowd primed and ready to cheer her on, Sarah Palin succeeded … maybe not surprisingly, but admirably.
I didn’t watch the whole speech, I’ll admit. My wife and I have been watching Buffy the Vampire Slayer on DVD lately, so we switched between butt-kickin’ heroines. And I don’t have a problem with saying Palin kicked a little butt last night. She had a great line about Obama’s foolish “bitter” comment. She had a slightly less great line about community organizers—actually pretty snide and unfair, but the crowd Luuuved it. And she got in a dig at Michelle Obama by saying how small town Americans “always” are proud of their country.
OK, so we know from this speech that she can attack the Obamas and media. And we know that John McCain is a great man. What else ya got?
At some point the R ticket really has to answer with something beside “Obama stinks.” They have to talk about the economy, about health care, about home foreclosures. They have to address education and energy—something beyond “we’ve got plenty of oil and gas on the North Range”—which, environmental concerns aside, simply isn’t true.
As they noted last night, great speeches aren’t enough. Vision is also required. And Sarah Palin’s Christianist, anti-choice, social Darwinist, anti-science vision of America is not a vision of this country’s future. It’s a vision of the past.
Speaking of a vision of the past, it was hard not to notice the Unbearable Whiteness of Being Republican last night when the cameras panned around the convention center. I mean, I expect to see fewer minorities at the RNC, but come on. I could count the number of African Americans I saw on one hand.
Now, how should the Obama camp respond to Palin’s speech? I’m thinking: the less said, the better. Let the R’s have their moment. Don’t come down like a ton of bricks on Palin and make her an even more sympathetic figure. Let McCain’s public nap, I mean, speech tonight pop the balloon all by itself. Or, if by chance he actually can match Palin (pretty unlikely, don’t you think?), give a lot of attention to the media’s fact checking.
For Palin,
it wasn’t pretty:
PALIN: "I have protected the taxpayers by vetoing wasteful spending ... and championed reform to end the abuses of earmark spending by Congress. I told the Congress 'thanks but no thanks' for that Bridge to Nowhere."
THE FACTS: As mayor of Wasilla, Palin hired a lobbyist and traveled to Washington annually to support earmarks for the town totaling $27 million. In her two years as governor, Alaska has requested nearly $750 million in special federal spending, by far the largest per-capita request in the nation. While Palin notes she rejected plans to build a $398 million bridge from Ketchikan to an island with 50 residents and an airport, that opposition came only after the plan was ridiculed nationally as a "bridge to nowhere."
PALIN: "There is much to like and admire about our opponent. But listening to him speak, it's easy to forget that this is a man who has authored two memoirs but not a single major law or reform — not even in the state senate."
THE FACTS: Compared to McCain and his two decades in the Senate, Obama does have a more meager record. But he has worked with Republicans to pass legislation that expanded efforts to intercept illegal shipments of weapons of mass destruction and to help destroy conventional weapons stockpiles. The legislation became law last year. To demean that accomplishment would be to also demean the work of Republican Sen. Richard Lugar of Indiana, a respected foreign policy voice in the Senate. In Illinois, he was the leader on two big, contentious measures in Illinois: studying racial profiling by police and requiring recordings of interrogations in potential death penalty cases. He also successfully co-sponsored major ethics reform legislation.
PALIN: "The Democratic nominee for president supports plans to raise income taxes, raise payroll taxes, raise investment income taxes, raise the death tax, raise business taxes, and increase the tax burden on the American people by hundreds of billions of dollars."
THE FACTS: The Tax Policy Center, a think tank run jointly by the Brookings Institution and the Urban Institute, concluded that Obama's plan would increase after-tax income for middle-income taxpayers by about 5 percent by 2012, or nearly $2,200 annually. McCain's plan, which cuts taxes across all income levels, would raise after tax-income for middle-income taxpayers by 3 percent, the center concluded.
(see the AP story for much more.)
Wednesday, September 03, 2008
Behind the Veil
A conservative friend just emailed me with some fairly boilerplate comments from Peggy Noonan (legendary conservative speechwriter for those of you unfamiliar). In those comments, she says the Left is going to attack Palin for being a strong conservative woman, it will get brutal, they're going to try to "kill her," etc.
The message, much as Fred Thompson (FRED! Good to see you again!) suggested last night, is that the Liberals and the Big Bad Media are in a panic over the virtuousness of Sarah Palin and her cause.
Riiiiiiight.
The truth is, this is just a lot of faux outrage. The McCain campaign is desperate. I know I use that word a lot, but time after time, it's the most appropriate for what McCain is doing. They're trying to whip up the conservative base and whatever women they can peel off, and they think they can do it by telling you the Liberal Media is Out To Get Sarah.
But behind the scenes, there's another story. Here's Peggy Noonan caught on an open mic saying "It's over," in reference to the McCain campaign, and calling the Palin-as-victim narrative "political bullshit."
And here's Joe Klein talking about how the McCain campaign is trying to bully the media into going easy on Palin.
Don't fall for the spin.
The message, much as Fred Thompson (FRED! Good to see you again!) suggested last night, is that the Liberals and the Big Bad Media are in a panic over the virtuousness of Sarah Palin and her cause.
Riiiiiiight.
The truth is, this is just a lot of faux outrage. The McCain campaign is desperate. I know I use that word a lot, but time after time, it's the most appropriate for what McCain is doing. They're trying to whip up the conservative base and whatever women they can peel off, and they think they can do it by telling you the Liberal Media is Out To Get Sarah.
But behind the scenes, there's another story. Here's Peggy Noonan caught on an open mic saying "It's over," in reference to the McCain campaign, and calling the Palin-as-victim narrative "political bullshit."
And here's Joe Klein talking about how the McCain campaign is trying to bully the media into going easy on Palin.
Don't fall for the spin.
No Accountability
This is depressing.
I think Gov. Sarah Palin is a bright and likable politician. She has a lovely family, and they are due privacy and respect. Her resume doesn’t have nearly enough meat to it to qualify her for vice president, in my opinion, but I know there are plenty of people who say the same about Barack Obama’s qualifications.
It just is kind of painful to see a promising career being trashed by the Republican Party.
That’s not a typo. The McCain campaign is lashing out at the media, as they’ve been lashing out at liberal bloggers and the Obama camp, trying to whip up a backlash against legitimate questions surround Palin and the McCain vetting process.
But it’s not the media or political opponents who are really doing the damage here.
By any standard, McCain botched his selection. Even if you accept the premise that Palin is qualified and her various issues are not serious enough to disqualify her, can anyone argue that McCain shouldn’t have handled this better? Made the decision earlier so that some of these issues wouldn’t be a huge distraction during the convention, maybe? Huddled with Palin more than one brief meeting in February so she’d be prepared for the media onslaught? Float a trial balloon, as he did with a possible Lieberman pick?
Instead, we’ve had a media circus entirely created by the McCain campaign’s incompetence. And what has that campaign done to address the questions that have come up? Have they had Palin sit down with select reporters to answer questions? Have they had a press conference? Have they even let her speak?
No. They’ve hidden her away, started stonewalling, hired the lawyers, and unleashed the GOP surrogates to attack the media and try to muddy the issues.
It’s really kind of disgusting. And it’s exactly the same Rovian, deflect-accountability-at-all-cost mindset that we’ve seen so often from the Bush Administration.
Do we really want another administration like that?
Palin will most likely give a good speech tonight. And the Republican faithful will continue to do their admirable mental gymnastics in embracing a political neophyte as the possible next President of the United States, an abstinence-promoting Family Values candidate with her own personal issues, a straight-talkin’ reformer who hides from the press and the American people.
It’s quite a spectacle.
Whatever Sarah Palin’s done, she doesn’t deserve this. And she has Sen. McCain, and the Bush GOP, to thank.
I think Gov. Sarah Palin is a bright and likable politician. She has a lovely family, and they are due privacy and respect. Her resume doesn’t have nearly enough meat to it to qualify her for vice president, in my opinion, but I know there are plenty of people who say the same about Barack Obama’s qualifications.
It just is kind of painful to see a promising career being trashed by the Republican Party.
That’s not a typo. The McCain campaign is lashing out at the media, as they’ve been lashing out at liberal bloggers and the Obama camp, trying to whip up a backlash against legitimate questions surround Palin and the McCain vetting process.
But it’s not the media or political opponents who are really doing the damage here.
By any standard, McCain botched his selection. Even if you accept the premise that Palin is qualified and her various issues are not serious enough to disqualify her, can anyone argue that McCain shouldn’t have handled this better? Made the decision earlier so that some of these issues wouldn’t be a huge distraction during the convention, maybe? Huddled with Palin more than one brief meeting in February so she’d be prepared for the media onslaught? Float a trial balloon, as he did with a possible Lieberman pick?
Instead, we’ve had a media circus entirely created by the McCain campaign’s incompetence. And what has that campaign done to address the questions that have come up? Have they had Palin sit down with select reporters to answer questions? Have they had a press conference? Have they even let her speak?
No. They’ve hidden her away, started stonewalling, hired the lawyers, and unleashed the GOP surrogates to attack the media and try to muddy the issues.
It’s really kind of disgusting. And it’s exactly the same Rovian, deflect-accountability-at-all-cost mindset that we’ve seen so often from the Bush Administration.
Do we really want another administration like that?
Palin will most likely give a good speech tonight. And the Republican faithful will continue to do their admirable mental gymnastics in embracing a political neophyte as the possible next President of the United States, an abstinence-promoting Family Values candidate with her own personal issues, a straight-talkin’ reformer who hides from the press and the American people.
It’s quite a spectacle.
Whatever Sarah Palin’s done, she doesn’t deserve this. And she has Sen. McCain, and the Bush GOP, to thank.
Tuesday, September 02, 2008
Country First - A Case Study
“ST. PAUL — A series of disclosures about Gov. Sarah Palin, Senator John McCain’s choice as running mate, called into question on Monday how thoroughly Mr. McCain had examined her background before putting her on the Republican presidential ticket.
On Monday morning, Ms. Palin and her husband, Todd, issued a statement saying that their 17-year-old unmarried daughter, Bristol, was five months pregnant and that she intended to marry the father.
Among other less attention-grabbing news of the day: it was learned that Ms. Palin now has a private lawyer in a legislative ethics investigation in Alaska into whether she abused her power in dismissing the state’s public safety commissioner; that she was a member for two years in the 1990s of the Alaska Independence Party, which has at times sought a vote on whether the state should secede; and that Mr. Palin was arrested 22 years ago on a drunken-driving charge.
Aides to Mr. McCain said they had a team on the ground in Alaska now to look more thoroughly into Ms. Palin’s background. A Republican with ties to the campaign said the team assigned to vet Ms. Palin in Alaska had not arrived there until Thursday, a day before Mr. McCain stunned the political world with his vice-presidential choice. The campaign was still calling Republican operatives as late as Sunday night asking them to go to Alaska to deal with the unexpected candidacy of Ms. Palin.
Although the McCain campaign said that Mr. McCain had known about Bristol Palin’s pregnancy before he asked her mother to join him on the ticket and that he did not consider it disqualifying, top aides were vague on Monday about how and when he had learned of the pregnancy, and from whom.”
New York Times, Elisabeth Bumiller, 9-2-08
The question is not about Sarah Palin’s experience or lack thereof, it is not about her daughter, it is not about 22-year-old drunken-driving charges. It is about the judgment and decision-making process of Sen. John McCain. The conventional wisdom was that the VP pick says a lot about how a candidate would approach his duties as President of the United States.
McCain had met Palin once before calling her to come to Arizona and do the final interview for the VP slot.
Is there any other case in memory of a candidate for President acting so hastily, so rashly, in a decision of this magnitude?
This is putting country first?
update: It appears that Sarah Palin was not a member of the AIP, but her husband was, and they both attended one of the group's conferences. The McCain campaign is pushing back hard against some of these issues, but both McCain and Palin have canceled interviews and appearances. Hiding won't help.
On Monday morning, Ms. Palin and her husband, Todd, issued a statement saying that their 17-year-old unmarried daughter, Bristol, was five months pregnant and that she intended to marry the father.
Among other less attention-grabbing news of the day: it was learned that Ms. Palin now has a private lawyer in a legislative ethics investigation in Alaska into whether she abused her power in dismissing the state’s public safety commissioner; that she was a member for two years in the 1990s of the Alaska Independence Party, which has at times sought a vote on whether the state should secede; and that Mr. Palin was arrested 22 years ago on a drunken-driving charge.
Aides to Mr. McCain said they had a team on the ground in Alaska now to look more thoroughly into Ms. Palin’s background. A Republican with ties to the campaign said the team assigned to vet Ms. Palin in Alaska had not arrived there until Thursday, a day before Mr. McCain stunned the political world with his vice-presidential choice. The campaign was still calling Republican operatives as late as Sunday night asking them to go to Alaska to deal with the unexpected candidacy of Ms. Palin.
Although the McCain campaign said that Mr. McCain had known about Bristol Palin’s pregnancy before he asked her mother to join him on the ticket and that he did not consider it disqualifying, top aides were vague on Monday about how and when he had learned of the pregnancy, and from whom.”
New York Times, Elisabeth Bumiller, 9-2-08
The question is not about Sarah Palin’s experience or lack thereof, it is not about her daughter, it is not about 22-year-old drunken-driving charges. It is about the judgment and decision-making process of Sen. John McCain. The conventional wisdom was that the VP pick says a lot about how a candidate would approach his duties as President of the United States.
McCain had met Palin once before calling her to come to Arizona and do the final interview for the VP slot.
Is there any other case in memory of a candidate for President acting so hastily, so rashly, in a decision of this magnitude?
This is putting country first?
update: It appears that Sarah Palin was not a member of the AIP, but her husband was, and they both attended one of the group's conferences. The McCain campaign is pushing back hard against some of these issues, but both McCain and Palin have canceled interviews and appearances. Hiding won't help.
Saturday, August 30, 2008
Palin by comparison
Well, I’m two for two in picking VPs …
Of course, I never actually predicted Gov. Sarah Palin would be McCain’s pick, just said I wondered if he would go that direction.
Ah, what the heck, close enough. I rule!!!
To use a tired cliché, what we have here is two candidates swinging for the fences. The reviews suggest that Obama hit a home run Thursday night, and judging from the conservative blogs, the Palin pick seems like a solid hit at least. But I wonder about the long-term effect.
As I noted before, Palin has some upside. And she might be a better matchup than some others in a VP debate with Biden. Despite her being inexperienced in foreign policy, Biden will have to tread carefully in the debate. It won’t be a repeat of the Bentsen-Quayle debate.
However, over time, I can’t help but believe that people are going to start thinking about that big “what if?” What if Sarah Palin becomes President of the United States due to something unfortunate happening to McCain? He’s not a young guy, he’s had health problems. People should and will ask that question. How will that prospect sit with people?
Obviously, McCain’s camp has decided to double down on “maverick” and double-fault on “inexperienced” as campaign themes. It’s a risky and bold move. Or desperate. Probably depends on your point of view.
There's a lot of discussion on how the Obama campaign should "attack" the pick. My thought is that they shouldn't spend too much time on it at all. People aren't voting for the VPs. They're voting for the top of the ticket. And this pick is significant not for what it says about Palin's experience, but for what it says about McCain's judgment and decision-making.
Other random thoughts:
Funny that the Republican candidates for president and vice president can’t stop talking about how great Hillary Clinton is.
Gotta feel for Tim Pawlenty. He worked very, very hard for McCain. Not much of a payoff.
Of course, I never actually predicted Gov. Sarah Palin would be McCain’s pick, just said I wondered if he would go that direction.
Ah, what the heck, close enough. I rule!!!
To use a tired cliché, what we have here is two candidates swinging for the fences. The reviews suggest that Obama hit a home run Thursday night, and judging from the conservative blogs, the Palin pick seems like a solid hit at least. But I wonder about the long-term effect.
As I noted before, Palin has some upside. And she might be a better matchup than some others in a VP debate with Biden. Despite her being inexperienced in foreign policy, Biden will have to tread carefully in the debate. It won’t be a repeat of the Bentsen-Quayle debate.
However, over time, I can’t help but believe that people are going to start thinking about that big “what if?” What if Sarah Palin becomes President of the United States due to something unfortunate happening to McCain? He’s not a young guy, he’s had health problems. People should and will ask that question. How will that prospect sit with people?
Obviously, McCain’s camp has decided to double down on “maverick” and double-fault on “inexperienced” as campaign themes. It’s a risky and bold move. Or desperate. Probably depends on your point of view.
There's a lot of discussion on how the Obama campaign should "attack" the pick. My thought is that they shouldn't spend too much time on it at all. People aren't voting for the VPs. They're voting for the top of the ticket. And this pick is significant not for what it says about Palin's experience, but for what it says about McCain's judgment and decision-making.
Other random thoughts:
Funny that the Republican candidates for president and vice president can’t stop talking about how great Hillary Clinton is.
Gotta feel for Tim Pawlenty. He worked very, very hard for McCain. Not much of a payoff.
Friday, August 29, 2008
5 Reasons Why My Head is Exploding
1. Who are you, and what have done with Pat Buchanan???
2. Most serious case of political whiplash in the last 50 years:
Last night: McCain camp slams “meager record” of Obama. “Barack Obama is still not ready to be President.”
Today: McCain names his VP pick: 44-year-old Sarah Palin, Governor of Alaska for two whole years. Before that: Mayor of Wasilla. Ready on day one, right?
3. Great speech aside, Barack Obama sums up a winning rationale for his candidacy in one word:
“ENOUGH!”
4. Thanks to TPM, a potatoe-worthy moment from the McCain Store. (image taken from McCain Web site, spelling since corrected.)

5. Gaffe Riots: They’ve been waaay overshadowed by everything else, but a couple of R bigwigs have said some monumentally dumb things in the past two days. Karl Rove says that because of things like inconvenient hurricanes, Republicans can’t catch a break. (The people of New Orleans feel for you, Karl.) And a guy that helped write the McCain health care policy (there’s some dispute about his exact relationship to the campaign) says that we can solve the health care problem of 45 million uninsured people by simply not calling them uninsured anymore. After all, he says, they can always go the emergency room.
2. Most serious case of political whiplash in the last 50 years:
Last night: McCain camp slams “meager record” of Obama. “Barack Obama is still not ready to be President.”
Today: McCain names his VP pick: 44-year-old Sarah Palin, Governor of Alaska for two whole years. Before that: Mayor of Wasilla. Ready on day one, right?
3. Great speech aside, Barack Obama sums up a winning rationale for his candidacy in one word:
“ENOUGH!”
4. Thanks to TPM, a potatoe-worthy moment from the McCain Store. (image taken from McCain Web site, spelling since corrected.)
5. Gaffe Riots: They’ve been waaay overshadowed by everything else, but a couple of R bigwigs have said some monumentally dumb things in the past two days. Karl Rove says that because of things like inconvenient hurricanes, Republicans can’t catch a break. (The people of New Orleans feel for you, Karl.) And a guy that helped write the McCain health care policy (there’s some dispute about his exact relationship to the campaign) says that we can solve the health care problem of 45 million uninsured people by simply not calling them uninsured anymore. After all, he says, they can always go the emergency room.
Thursday, August 28, 2008
History
Remember when we were wishing for the primary season to be over and that the Dems would finally, finally settle on a candidate?
Well, they have.
"DENVER — Sen. Barack Obama was nominated by his party on Wednesday to be the 44th president of the United States, becoming the first African-American to receive a major party nomination.
With a unanimous vote, the freshman senator from Illinois defeated the first family of Democratic Party politics with a call for a fundamentally new course in politics.
It brought to an end an often-bitter two-year political struggle for the nomination with Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton, who, standing on a packed convention floor electric with anticipation, moved to halt the roll call in progress so that the convention could nominate Obama by acclamation."
Adam Nagouney, NYT
I spent the evening cooking dinner, trying to get my kids to eat, cleaning up dinner, getting their DVD started, taking out the garbage, and putting them to bed. My wife was working her second job until after the kids were in bed. Just an average day for us, but a very significant day in American history.
I didn't see any of the speeches, but heard a little today on NPR. In order to keep from clogging the blog with video boxes, I'll just put one up. Bill Clinton was very good, from what I heard. John Kerry got rave reviews from the left, don't know how he sounded to others. And if you get a chance to see Beau Biden's short intro to his dad's speech, that's good too. But the one I was most interested in was Joe Biden's. Here it is.
Well, they have.
"DENVER — Sen. Barack Obama was nominated by his party on Wednesday to be the 44th president of the United States, becoming the first African-American to receive a major party nomination.
With a unanimous vote, the freshman senator from Illinois defeated the first family of Democratic Party politics with a call for a fundamentally new course in politics.
It brought to an end an often-bitter two-year political struggle for the nomination with Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton, who, standing on a packed convention floor electric with anticipation, moved to halt the roll call in progress so that the convention could nominate Obama by acclamation."
Adam Nagouney, NYT
I spent the evening cooking dinner, trying to get my kids to eat, cleaning up dinner, getting their DVD started, taking out the garbage, and putting them to bed. My wife was working her second job until after the kids were in bed. Just an average day for us, but a very significant day in American history.
I didn't see any of the speeches, but heard a little today on NPR. In order to keep from clogging the blog with video boxes, I'll just put one up. Bill Clinton was very good, from what I heard. John Kerry got rave reviews from the left, don't know how he sounded to others. And if you get a chance to see Beau Biden's short intro to his dad's speech, that's good too. But the one I was most interested in was Joe Biden's. Here it is.
Wednesday, August 27, 2008
“Let’s never forget, we’re the real story, not them.”
“What do you think the Devil is going to look like if he's around? Nobody is going to be taken in if he has a long, red, pointy tail. No. I'm semi-serious here. He will look attractive and he will be nice and helpful and he will get a job where he influences a great God-fearing nation and he will never do an evil thing... he will just bit by little bit lower standards where they are important. Just coax along flash over substance... Just a tiny bit.” – Aaron Altman, Broadcast News
I was thinking of Broadcast News last night, because I was more or less fuming at the empty suits the major networks are using to cover the DNC.
Now, I’ve gone out of my way in the past to defend the media. It’s an easy target that everyone likes to pick on. When you feel strongly about a party or a candidate you’re bound to see bias in the way that the media covers elections. It’s pretty much human nature. So I don’t buy the “the media has a political axe to grind” conspiracy theories for the most part.
But last night was a shining example of how it’s not the bias, it’s the stupidity that is the real problem with television news coverage of politics.
I was trying to watch the gosh-darned convention, and I couldn’t because these plastic people were talking nonstop, telling me what I should think about the convention. On six out of the seven channels, the pundits were blathering on over the speakers. At one point, one of them was saying, “The Democrats should be attacking McCain more!” I then turned to PBS (the one channel that seemed to actually allow us to see the convention speakers not named Clinton) and the guy at the podium was bashing McCain! At the very same time! If the pundit had turned around and listened for one minute, he’d have seen the very thing he claimed was missing!
And then there was the reaction to Clinton’s speech. I turned to Fox News and they were somberly saying how she didn’t seem to “really” praise Obama and support his candidacy. I then turned to CNN and they were saying what a great job she did in praising Obama and supporting his candidacy.
It just goes to show how useless these pundits are. Let’s be honest, most of them are paid to look good in a suit and speak clearly. They’re not great thinkers. They don’t even have to be well-informed, obviously.
So why are they on my television??
If you missed it, here’s Sen. Clinton and Mark Warner. Warner’s speech was more low-key, but a good message for Democrats, I think. “This election is not about liberal versus conservative. It’s not about left versus right. It’s about the future versus the past.”
I was thinking of Broadcast News last night, because I was more or less fuming at the empty suits the major networks are using to cover the DNC.
Now, I’ve gone out of my way in the past to defend the media. It’s an easy target that everyone likes to pick on. When you feel strongly about a party or a candidate you’re bound to see bias in the way that the media covers elections. It’s pretty much human nature. So I don’t buy the “the media has a political axe to grind” conspiracy theories for the most part.
But last night was a shining example of how it’s not the bias, it’s the stupidity that is the real problem with television news coverage of politics.
I was trying to watch the gosh-darned convention, and I couldn’t because these plastic people were talking nonstop, telling me what I should think about the convention. On six out of the seven channels, the pundits were blathering on over the speakers. At one point, one of them was saying, “The Democrats should be attacking McCain more!” I then turned to PBS (the one channel that seemed to actually allow us to see the convention speakers not named Clinton) and the guy at the podium was bashing McCain! At the very same time! If the pundit had turned around and listened for one minute, he’d have seen the very thing he claimed was missing!
And then there was the reaction to Clinton’s speech. I turned to Fox News and they were somberly saying how she didn’t seem to “really” praise Obama and support his candidacy. I then turned to CNN and they were saying what a great job she did in praising Obama and supporting his candidacy.
It just goes to show how useless these pundits are. Let’s be honest, most of them are paid to look good in a suit and speak clearly. They’re not great thinkers. They don’t even have to be well-informed, obviously.
So why are they on my television??
If you missed it, here’s Sen. Clinton and Mark Warner. Warner’s speech was more low-key, but a good message for Democrats, I think. “This election is not about liberal versus conservative. It’s not about left versus right. It’s about the future versus the past.”
Tuesday, August 26, 2008
Monday, August 25, 2008
Morning, Joe
So, we just got back from a few days on the North Shore, far from the city, jobs, internet connections, etc.
Did anything happen over the weekend?
Oh, that. Well, I can now crow about how I correctly picked Biden as Obama's VP choice. Me and about 4 billion other people.
I think it's a good choice; every candidate would've had strengths and weaknesses, but I like Biden's working-class background and lengthy foreign policy resume. All indications are that Biden will make an effective attack dog--and there seems to be some consensus around the idea that Obama needs one.
As I mentioned below, I also think the selection of Biden complicates things for McCain in picking a VP. Going with Pawlenty, who I think was a top contender, seems a little more dicey now because Biden might really take him apart in the VP debate, and might seem more "vice-presidential" in general. I'm kind of a fan of Pawlenty, but I really don't see that comparison working too well for the R's.
But then who does McCain go with? Romney was the other strong contender, but this whole "housing confusion" issue has got to make the McCain camp skittish about picking another ultra-wealthy guy. So now what? The Lieberman/Ridge trial balloon has not gone well for McCain, the R base is just not going to go for a pro-choice VP pick. Who does that leave?
You got me. I wonder if McCain might pick Sarah Palin or Carly Fiorina. One of the big problems demographically for McCain is that women break strongly for Obama (and in general for D candidates). However, with the Hillary issue, McCain seems to think he has an opening to pull in a few more women voters who are dissatisfied with how the Dem. primary came out. I personally doubt that the Hillary issue is that big of a deal, but McCain has been pushing that button pretty hard. So maybe go with a woman VP? That would also make it harder for Biden to dominate the VP debate--he would have to worry about coming on too strong against a female candidate and generating a backlash.
The problem for McCain is that most of the likely women contenders have their own downsides (lack of experience, for one). Hey, maybe he'll pick Michelle Bachmann. She's about as pro-life as you can get, a very gung-ho supporter of the military, and a poster girl for the religious right. She's also a little crazy, but in a pleasant, photogenic way.
Come on, John. Shake things up a little! McCain/Bachmann 08!
Did anything happen over the weekend?
Oh, that. Well, I can now crow about how I correctly picked Biden as Obama's VP choice. Me and about 4 billion other people.
I think it's a good choice; every candidate would've had strengths and weaknesses, but I like Biden's working-class background and lengthy foreign policy resume. All indications are that Biden will make an effective attack dog--and there seems to be some consensus around the idea that Obama needs one.
As I mentioned below, I also think the selection of Biden complicates things for McCain in picking a VP. Going with Pawlenty, who I think was a top contender, seems a little more dicey now because Biden might really take him apart in the VP debate, and might seem more "vice-presidential" in general. I'm kind of a fan of Pawlenty, but I really don't see that comparison working too well for the R's.
But then who does McCain go with? Romney was the other strong contender, but this whole "housing confusion" issue has got to make the McCain camp skittish about picking another ultra-wealthy guy. So now what? The Lieberman/Ridge trial balloon has not gone well for McCain, the R base is just not going to go for a pro-choice VP pick. Who does that leave?
You got me. I wonder if McCain might pick Sarah Palin or Carly Fiorina. One of the big problems demographically for McCain is that women break strongly for Obama (and in general for D candidates). However, with the Hillary issue, McCain seems to think he has an opening to pull in a few more women voters who are dissatisfied with how the Dem. primary came out. I personally doubt that the Hillary issue is that big of a deal, but McCain has been pushing that button pretty hard. So maybe go with a woman VP? That would also make it harder for Biden to dominate the VP debate--he would have to worry about coming on too strong against a female candidate and generating a backlash.
The problem for McCain is that most of the likely women contenders have their own downsides (lack of experience, for one). Hey, maybe he'll pick Michelle Bachmann. She's about as pro-life as you can get, a very gung-ho supporter of the military, and a poster girl for the religious right. She's also a little crazy, but in a pleasant, photogenic way.
Come on, John. Shake things up a little! McCain/Bachmann 08!
Wednesday, August 20, 2008
Always a Risky Tactic
"In one sense, the grand experiment at the heart of the Obama campaign is an effort to win the election by speaking to the voters like adults."
From a post at TPM.
From a post at TPM.
Recipe for a Landslide: Let Obama be Obama
People on the Obama side of this year’s election are little stressed right now. The polls are starting to look better for McCain (he’s up five points in one poll today), and there’s the whole slimy “Obama is a celebrity” attack ad phenomenon—which reminds people of Swiftboating and seems to be working, unfortunately. Plus the Georgian crisis plays into McCain’s strengths. And now that “Saddleback” forum, where McCain got good-to-glowing reviews, has a lot of people worried. Shocking, isn’t it, that a conservative evangelical forum, where McCain tells the audience what it wants to hear and Obama doesn’t, turns out to work better for McCain?
I understand the anxiety. But the campaign really has barely gotten out of the starting gate at this point. We have VPs to pick, conventions to get through, debates, and any number of new, unforeseen developments ahead of us as the race progresses.
To me, the odds are still strongly in Obama’s favor. In fact, if I were to bet, I would bet that Obama will win decisively in the fall. Keep in mind, I’ve been very wrong before. But just looking at the challenges before both candidates, I like Obama’s chances much better. And I think the key to his chances is to let him be himself.
Town hall meetings are fine, and Obama should keep doing them. But he also needs to do rallies, speeches, and big events to fire up his base and get the attention of independent voters. Let the McCain campaign call him a “celebrity.” Ronald Reagan was a celebrity. John F. Kennedy was a celebrity. Obama should stand up in front of 50,000 people and say, “Are you here to see a celebrity, or are you here because you want to see a better tomorrow for this country?” And put the response in every TV ad he broadcasts.
People in this country want change. They need to be reminded that John McCain, despite his maverick image, has come to embrace Bush Republicanism. That is a tragedy for McCain, and it will be a tragedy for our country if we vote for four more years of it.
The polls at this point are not meaningless, but they are not at all a good guide for the outcome in November. Barring torrential rain or a Clinton meltdown, Obama should get a good bounce out of the Democratic convention. I think the debates will also be better for Obama than some might suspect. And Obama’s ground game, the enthusiasm gap, the number of new voters, all of this gives him advantages that no other Democratic candidate has had in recent memory.
There’s a long way to go. McCain’s doing better than expected. But things really are just getting started. And Obama is a proven winner.
I understand the anxiety. But the campaign really has barely gotten out of the starting gate at this point. We have VPs to pick, conventions to get through, debates, and any number of new, unforeseen developments ahead of us as the race progresses.
To me, the odds are still strongly in Obama’s favor. In fact, if I were to bet, I would bet that Obama will win decisively in the fall. Keep in mind, I’ve been very wrong before. But just looking at the challenges before both candidates, I like Obama’s chances much better. And I think the key to his chances is to let him be himself.
Town hall meetings are fine, and Obama should keep doing them. But he also needs to do rallies, speeches, and big events to fire up his base and get the attention of independent voters. Let the McCain campaign call him a “celebrity.” Ronald Reagan was a celebrity. John F. Kennedy was a celebrity. Obama should stand up in front of 50,000 people and say, “Are you here to see a celebrity, or are you here because you want to see a better tomorrow for this country?” And put the response in every TV ad he broadcasts.
People in this country want change. They need to be reminded that John McCain, despite his maverick image, has come to embrace Bush Republicanism. That is a tragedy for McCain, and it will be a tragedy for our country if we vote for four more years of it.
The polls at this point are not meaningless, but they are not at all a good guide for the outcome in November. Barring torrential rain or a Clinton meltdown, Obama should get a good bounce out of the Democratic convention. I think the debates will also be better for Obama than some might suspect. And Obama’s ground game, the enthusiasm gap, the number of new voters, all of this gives him advantages that no other Democratic candidate has had in recent memory.
There’s a long way to go. McCain’s doing better than expected. But things really are just getting started. And Obama is a proven winner.
Monday, August 18, 2008
Biden, His Time
I'm sorry, I'm sorry, I could not resist...
OK, so it's looking more and more like Obama's pick for VP is going to be Sen. Joe Biden. Of course, nothing's for certain. Bayh is a possibility, as are a couple of other people. But just looking at the way things are going right now, I'm thinking Obama wants to send a signal that he's going to have an experienced, well-respected foreign policy guy at his side. Biden's the best fit for that.
So what's interesting to me is: what McCain does do in response, assuming that Joe B. is the guy? Obviously, he doesn't need to shore up his foreign policy credentials (oh, we could get into that, but I'm not gonna). So does he pick the Pride of Minnesota, Tim Pawlenty?
He could do a lot worse. Pawlenty is a very likable and smart politician. He doesn't come across as extreme or inflexible. He could appeal to younger voters while not alienating older voters. People say his lack of a national profile is a minus, but as someone who's been following his career, I've seen him on the national stage in various capacities, and he does allright in the spotlight.
But how does picking Pawlenty look if Biden is the VP candidate on the other side? I’m wondering if memories of Dan Quayle will scare off the McCain team. Now, Pawlenty is no Dan Quayle, far from it. But will they give him a chance to prove it?
Obviously, McCain doesn’t need an older, experienced hand as No. 2; he’s got the old, experienced thing down pretty cold. Still, when the VP debate rolls around in the fall, are they gonna want the relatively inexperienced Pawlenty to go up against Biden? Or will they see such a matchup as a plus?
OK, so it's looking more and more like Obama's pick for VP is going to be Sen. Joe Biden. Of course, nothing's for certain. Bayh is a possibility, as are a couple of other people. But just looking at the way things are going right now, I'm thinking Obama wants to send a signal that he's going to have an experienced, well-respected foreign policy guy at his side. Biden's the best fit for that.
So what's interesting to me is: what McCain does do in response, assuming that Joe B. is the guy? Obviously, he doesn't need to shore up his foreign policy credentials (oh, we could get into that, but I'm not gonna). So does he pick the Pride of Minnesota, Tim Pawlenty?
He could do a lot worse. Pawlenty is a very likable and smart politician. He doesn't come across as extreme or inflexible. He could appeal to younger voters while not alienating older voters. People say his lack of a national profile is a minus, but as someone who's been following his career, I've seen him on the national stage in various capacities, and he does allright in the spotlight.
But how does picking Pawlenty look if Biden is the VP candidate on the other side? I’m wondering if memories of Dan Quayle will scare off the McCain team. Now, Pawlenty is no Dan Quayle, far from it. But will they give him a chance to prove it?
Obviously, McCain doesn’t need an older, experienced hand as No. 2; he’s got the old, experienced thing down pretty cold. Still, when the VP debate rolls around in the fall, are they gonna want the relatively inexperienced Pawlenty to go up against Biden? Or will they see such a matchup as a plus?
Thursday, August 14, 2008
EFT on the Turnabout post
EFT has commented on the Turnabout post below, but Blogger apparently is having issues ... so I'm just reprinting it as a new post. I'll probably have a response in the comments section. Thanks for the feedback!
from EFT:
That video is a partisan, one-sided case of fear-mongering. And its hypothetical pro-Republican/anti-Democrat counterpart would be as well. That's not to say that it doesn't leave us some points to ponder.
Looking at history, it's difficult to find a well-known president who isn't associated with a war or tough guy image: Washington, Lincoln, Roosevelt(s), Kennedy, Nixon, Reagan, etc. Sometimes a president's military training is the source and sometimes it's circumstances, but either way it seems that strong, memorable presidents are linked to war and it certainly shaped their policies and politics. I don't know if that's necessarily good, but it's a fact that those are the leaders that stand out in the history books. BTW, those same history books usually fail to point out that even after a victory, the US maintains a military presence in the country-sort of an occupying force though that's not the term used. We have bases in Vietnam, Korea, Germany, and now Iraq. Apparently, it's easier to keep an eye on your former enemy if you're closer to them--and there's over 60 years of evidence to show that, despite changes in administration.
Being a Cold War kid, I have always been suspicious of Russia-regardless of how many times that country is classed as our friend or ally. As a nation, they have allowed their nuclear arsenal to be distributed to their former republics and rogue nations...seemingly without any concern for passing along the knowledge, restraint, and guidance needed to handle those weapons responsibly.
It's kind of like having a gun in the house. If the owner isn't responsible and fails to make sure that everyone with access has been properly trained, then it's just a tragedy waiting to happen.
But, to answer your last question, I do feel lucky. The election this fall pits a former POW against a candidate who is truly free of military influence. Either way we'll win. If McCain is in, then we'll have a president who understands deeply what can happen when things go awry in a war. If it's Obama, we'll have, for the very first time, a president untouched by war as a veteran or a draft dodger...a clean slate if you will. Both bring a fresh perspective to the questions surrounding the Iraq, Afghanistan, and Middle East situations.
from EFT:
That video is a partisan, one-sided case of fear-mongering. And its hypothetical pro-Republican/anti-Democrat counterpart would be as well. That's not to say that it doesn't leave us some points to ponder.
Looking at history, it's difficult to find a well-known president who isn't associated with a war or tough guy image: Washington, Lincoln, Roosevelt(s), Kennedy, Nixon, Reagan, etc. Sometimes a president's military training is the source and sometimes it's circumstances, but either way it seems that strong, memorable presidents are linked to war and it certainly shaped their policies and politics. I don't know if that's necessarily good, but it's a fact that those are the leaders that stand out in the history books. BTW, those same history books usually fail to point out that even after a victory, the US maintains a military presence in the country-sort of an occupying force though that's not the term used. We have bases in Vietnam, Korea, Germany, and now Iraq. Apparently, it's easier to keep an eye on your former enemy if you're closer to them--and there's over 60 years of evidence to show that, despite changes in administration.
Being a Cold War kid, I have always been suspicious of Russia-regardless of how many times that country is classed as our friend or ally. As a nation, they have allowed their nuclear arsenal to be distributed to their former republics and rogue nations...seemingly without any concern for passing along the knowledge, restraint, and guidance needed to handle those weapons responsibly.
It's kind of like having a gun in the house. If the owner isn't responsible and fails to make sure that everyone with access has been properly trained, then it's just a tragedy waiting to happen.
But, to answer your last question, I do feel lucky. The election this fall pits a former POW against a candidate who is truly free of military influence. Either way we'll win. If McCain is in, then we'll have a president who understands deeply what can happen when things go awry in a war. If it's Obama, we'll have, for the very first time, a president untouched by war as a veteran or a draft dodger...a clean slate if you will. Both bring a fresh perspective to the questions surrounding the Iraq, Afghanistan, and Middle East situations.
Wednesday, August 13, 2008
Biden for VP?
There's some talk of it amongst Obama watchers. I think that would be great. He has experience, plenty of cred in the foreign policy field, is old, and is really pretty down to earth. I don't think you can hit him with the "elitist" tag (he rides the subway to and from work every day, according to WaPo), and yet he's smart and talks to people like grownups, something the current prez and Sen. McCain don't always do.
I think it's fair to say that people want change with this election, but they are still needing some reassurance about Obama. Biden helps him with that, more than a lot of the names that have been thrown about. Maybe more than anyone. Oh, and he's Catholic, too, so there's another voting bloc checked off the list. (I realize the D's won't get all the Catholics. But Biden could help.)
What else is going on? Republicans are supporting Obama.
Also, there's a campaign, to put the Obama logo on barns in Ohio, which I think is cool. Who knows how it will affect votes, probably not much, but it's good to see the Dem candidate's campaign trying to appeal to rural voters and being creative about it.
I think it's fair to say that people want change with this election, but they are still needing some reassurance about Obama. Biden helps him with that, more than a lot of the names that have been thrown about. Maybe more than anyone. Oh, and he's Catholic, too, so there's another voting bloc checked off the list. (I realize the D's won't get all the Catholics. But Biden could help.)
What else is going on? Republicans are supporting Obama.
Also, there's a campaign, to put the Obama logo on barns in Ohio, which I think is cool. Who knows how it will affect votes, probably not much, but it's good to see the Dem candidate's campaign trying to appeal to rural voters and being creative about it.
Monday, August 11, 2008
Turnabout: Fair Play?
Republican candidates in recent years have been pretty straightforward with the equation--A Vote for a Democrat Endangers America. I mean, they don’t always come out and say it just like that. But that’s pretty clearly the message at times. At other times they do come out and say it just like that.
Well, here’s a twist on that approach.
At first, I felt this video could be dismissed as a partisan, one-sided case of fear-mongering. One can make the case that the McCain statements quoted here are just typical Republican tough-guy posturing that’s necessary to win the nomination.
But hold on a minute. Isn’t typical Republican tough-guy posturing kind of the point here? Hasn’t that been, at root, a large part of the problem that has led us to disaster in Iraq and impotence elsewhere?
It ‘s pretty clear that McCain is surrounding himself with Rove and Cheney apostles, who believe that saber-rattlin’ and war-presidentin’ is both good policy AND good politics. A frightening combination, in my opinion.
One thing is beyond doubt: the threat posed by what might happen if someone like Bin Laden somehow someday gets ahold of nuclear materials is drawfed by the threat posed if a nation with thousands of nuclear weapons and high-tech delivery systems is suddenly back in an antagonistic posture with the United States.
And here is McCain, talking very belligerently about Russia. I guess the question that remains is: do you feel lucky, nation?
Well, do ya?
Well, here’s a twist on that approach.
At first, I felt this video could be dismissed as a partisan, one-sided case of fear-mongering. One can make the case that the McCain statements quoted here are just typical Republican tough-guy posturing that’s necessary to win the nomination.
But hold on a minute. Isn’t typical Republican tough-guy posturing kind of the point here? Hasn’t that been, at root, a large part of the problem that has led us to disaster in Iraq and impotence elsewhere?
It ‘s pretty clear that McCain is surrounding himself with Rove and Cheney apostles, who believe that saber-rattlin’ and war-presidentin’ is both good policy AND good politics. A frightening combination, in my opinion.
One thing is beyond doubt: the threat posed by what might happen if someone like Bin Laden somehow someday gets ahold of nuclear materials is drawfed by the threat posed if a nation with thousands of nuclear weapons and high-tech delivery systems is suddenly back in an antagonistic posture with the United States.
And here is McCain, talking very belligerently about Russia. I guess the question that remains is: do you feel lucky, nation?
Well, do ya?
Tuesday, August 05, 2008
Deja Vu All Over Again
I recognize that it’s not only possible to get too caught up in McCain’s attack ads from last week, it’s probably exactly what the McCain campaign wants us to do. But I do think it’s worth a little further comment, since last week was really pretty remarkable both in what happened and what it suggests for the campaign to come.
What we seem to be seeing is the McCain embrace of Rovian, Atwater-esque, good-old fashioned GOP attack politics.
We’ve seen it clearly in the past few presidential elections. In the mid-summer of 2000, the “Al Gore is an exaggerator/liar” theme was introduced and became the conventional wisdom of that fall, even though it was based on very little of substance. In mid-summer 2006, we saw the Swift Boat smear get its start, and the “Kerry is a flip-flopper” theme take hold. The Swift Boat stuff was despicable and dishonest, the flip-flopper theme, unfortunately, was not entirely without substance. One can argue that anyone in the Senate could be hit with that tag (and McCain is a great example of this), but Kerry’s difficulties in communicating well and acting decisively was a gift to his political opponents.
So now the GOP candidate is once again seeking an angle to attack. And so here in mid-summer, the “Obama is an elitist/celebrity” theme has been unveiled. And really, for the McCain camp, you have to say, so far, so good. Obama’s poll numbers seem to be going down a bit, the media is jumping all over itself to examine the signficance of what kind of tea and salad Obama prefers, and as an added bonus, Sen. McCain was able to grasp the thin reed of “I don’t look like the presidents on the currency” remark and turn it into The Race Card, thereby claiming victimhood. It was a solid week for him.
Of course, it was also Exhibit A of why we should all be embarrassed and angry over what our electoral politics have become.
So what should we expect in the coming weeks? Well, it would be easy to say “more of the same.” And I expect there will be more of the character attacks on Obama. But will it be effective in the long run? It could backfire on McCain; he’s obviously taking a bit of a beating over this strategy from at least some pundits.
Say what you want about celebrity, it was John McCain’s celebrity with the media that allowed him to build his image as a bi-partisan, reasonable, fair-minded politician for all these years. This strategy puts all that at risk.
Obama has a very fine line to walk between responding in a strong, effective way, and sounding angry, bitter, etc. But based on how he’s handled stuff so far, and on his performance against HRC, I’d say he’s better equipped to deal with this than any Dem presidential candidate since at least 1996.
Note for comparison Obama’s hard-hitting ads released this week, which do criticize McCain, but over a legitimate policy difference with real implications for voters.
Maybe Americans would rather talk about Paris Hilton and arugula than the issues. I hope not.
What we seem to be seeing is the McCain embrace of Rovian, Atwater-esque, good-old fashioned GOP attack politics.
We’ve seen it clearly in the past few presidential elections. In the mid-summer of 2000, the “Al Gore is an exaggerator/liar” theme was introduced and became the conventional wisdom of that fall, even though it was based on very little of substance. In mid-summer 2006, we saw the Swift Boat smear get its start, and the “Kerry is a flip-flopper” theme take hold. The Swift Boat stuff was despicable and dishonest, the flip-flopper theme, unfortunately, was not entirely without substance. One can argue that anyone in the Senate could be hit with that tag (and McCain is a great example of this), but Kerry’s difficulties in communicating well and acting decisively was a gift to his political opponents.
So now the GOP candidate is once again seeking an angle to attack. And so here in mid-summer, the “Obama is an elitist/celebrity” theme has been unveiled. And really, for the McCain camp, you have to say, so far, so good. Obama’s poll numbers seem to be going down a bit, the media is jumping all over itself to examine the signficance of what kind of tea and salad Obama prefers, and as an added bonus, Sen. McCain was able to grasp the thin reed of “I don’t look like the presidents on the currency” remark and turn it into The Race Card, thereby claiming victimhood. It was a solid week for him.
Of course, it was also Exhibit A of why we should all be embarrassed and angry over what our electoral politics have become.
So what should we expect in the coming weeks? Well, it would be easy to say “more of the same.” And I expect there will be more of the character attacks on Obama. But will it be effective in the long run? It could backfire on McCain; he’s obviously taking a bit of a beating over this strategy from at least some pundits.
Say what you want about celebrity, it was John McCain’s celebrity with the media that allowed him to build his image as a bi-partisan, reasonable, fair-minded politician for all these years. This strategy puts all that at risk.
Obama has a very fine line to walk between responding in a strong, effective way, and sounding angry, bitter, etc. But based on how he’s handled stuff so far, and on his performance against HRC, I’d say he’s better equipped to deal with this than any Dem presidential candidate since at least 1996.
Note for comparison Obama’s hard-hitting ads released this week, which do criticize McCain, but over a legitimate policy difference with real implications for voters.
Maybe Americans would rather talk about Paris Hilton and arugula than the issues. I hope not.
Thursday, July 31, 2008
The Race Card. Really?
“McCain Camp accuses Obama of playing the race card”— AP
Let me get this straight, McCain campaign. You run an ad attacking Obama for being a “celebrity,” and you show pictures of him, Brittney Spears and Paris Hilton in the ad. And then you accuse him of taking the low road? Really?
You put an African American man in an ad with two young white girls, and then you act shocked that someone draws a racial inference? Really? That surprises you? Huh.
When Obama says of himself: “He’s new, he doesn’t look like other presidents on the currency. He’s got a funny name,” you say that he’s playing the race card from the bottom of the deck? Really? That seems out of line to you? Really?
You criticize Obama for not going to Iraq, for not having international experience, and then when he has a successful trip to the Middle East and Europe, you criticize and mock him for doing so? Really? That seem consistent to you? Really?
You say he won’t make time to visit with US troops because he’d rather go the gym, and then the shot of him at the “gym” is actually a shot of him visiting with US troops? Really? That makes sense to you? Seriously?
But my question to you is, really, what happened to John McCain? Really. Is this slimy rope-a-dope, taunt your opponent and then use his mild response to attack him some more really what McCain thinks is going to win the election for him? Really? You think Obama is going to fall for this stuff like Kerry did? Really? Seriously?
You think that being popular, being a “celebrity” is really a bad thing? Really? You sure? ‘Cause it seems like when you’re whining about not getting enough press coverage that you kind of want to be more of a celebrity yourself. Really, it does.
You think the American people are stupid enough to fall for this bullshit again? Really?
(I don’t know if I have a lot of conservative readers, but I’m pretty sure I have some Independent ones. I’d be interested in hearing how they see this tactic that the McCain team has embraced. This stuff working for you?)
Let me get this straight, McCain campaign. You run an ad attacking Obama for being a “celebrity,” and you show pictures of him, Brittney Spears and Paris Hilton in the ad. And then you accuse him of taking the low road? Really?
You put an African American man in an ad with two young white girls, and then you act shocked that someone draws a racial inference? Really? That surprises you? Huh.
When Obama says of himself: “He’s new, he doesn’t look like other presidents on the currency. He’s got a funny name,” you say that he’s playing the race card from the bottom of the deck? Really? That seems out of line to you? Really?
You criticize Obama for not going to Iraq, for not having international experience, and then when he has a successful trip to the Middle East and Europe, you criticize and mock him for doing so? Really? That seem consistent to you? Really?
You say he won’t make time to visit with US troops because he’d rather go the gym, and then the shot of him at the “gym” is actually a shot of him visiting with US troops? Really? That makes sense to you? Seriously?
But my question to you is, really, what happened to John McCain? Really. Is this slimy rope-a-dope, taunt your opponent and then use his mild response to attack him some more really what McCain thinks is going to win the election for him? Really? You think Obama is going to fall for this stuff like Kerry did? Really? Seriously?
You think that being popular, being a “celebrity” is really a bad thing? Really? You sure? ‘Cause it seems like when you’re whining about not getting enough press coverage that you kind of want to be more of a celebrity yourself. Really, it does.
You think the American people are stupid enough to fall for this bullshit again? Really?
(I don’t know if I have a lot of conservative readers, but I’m pretty sure I have some Independent ones. I’d be interested in hearing how they see this tactic that the McCain team has embraced. This stuff working for you?)
Wednesday, July 30, 2008
More Documentation that Sen. McCain's Pants are on Fire
"McCain Charge Against Obama Lacks Evidence" - Washington Post
"McCain's advisers said they do not intend to back down from the charge, believing it an effective way to create a "narrative" about what they say is Obama's indifference toward the military."
That's their story and they're sticking to it. Even though they made it up. Karl Rove is smiling. Hey, it worked for the Swiftboaters.
"McCain's advisers said they do not intend to back down from the charge, believing it an effective way to create a "narrative" about what they say is Obama's indifference toward the military."
That's their story and they're sticking to it. Even though they made it up. Karl Rove is smiling. Hey, it worked for the Swiftboaters.
Monday, July 28, 2008
McCain: Into the Mud
Today I saw two items that nicely sum up my mixed feelings about Sen. John McCain. One was how he has to be very vigilant about skin cancer, due to his time as a POW, where he was apparently in the sun an unhealthy amount (added to all the other unhealthy things that happened). It reminded me of how much he sacrificed for this country, and how much I respect that.
But on the other hand, he is now running a campaign that regularly resorts to outright lies and smears in its political ads. The latest is the TV ad that claims Obama canceled a trip to visit wounded US service members because he couldn't take along TV cameras. As Andrea Mitchell (a journalist who has well-known conservative links) points out, this is simply not true.
There's more on this here
McCain vowed to run an honorable and dignified campaign. That is a broken promise. And we're only in July.
But on the other hand, he is now running a campaign that regularly resorts to outright lies and smears in its political ads. The latest is the TV ad that claims Obama canceled a trip to visit wounded US service members because he couldn't take along TV cameras. As Andrea Mitchell (a journalist who has well-known conservative links) points out, this is simply not true.
There's more on this here
McCain vowed to run an honorable and dignified campaign. That is a broken promise. And we're only in July.
Wednesday, July 23, 2008
Not-So-Quiet Desperation
John McCain wants you to know the Surge is working. No, scratch that, it is succeeding. Actually, it already has succeeded. We’re not only winning, we’ve won, and we’ll continue to keep winning, for however long it takes. Maybe a hundred years?
This incoherent line of thought is, believe it or not, McCain’s strongest argument at the moment. It is a relatively strong point to note that Obama said the Surge would fail, when as it turns out, the Surge seems to be a factor in the improving security situation in Iraq. This success can be overstated—Americans, being human, tend to oversimplify and see their own actions as being the most important. The reasons for the improving situation in Iraq are many, and they include the Surge. Be that as it may, Obama’s call was wrong on this one. So he’s batting 800 instead of a 1,000 on Iraq. That’s still a better average than McCain or most Republicans can claim.
As Obama’s overseas tour continues, though, it seems to me that McCain has made a significant mistake. His campaign was obviously worried that Obama’s trip would suck up a huge amount of oxygen, and that people would forget about McCain. That’s a legitimate worry; the media are treating this as a Very Big Deal.
But in his efforts to remind people that this is a two-person campaign, McCain has resorted to shouting, jumping up and down, and waving his arms. It’s not a good tactic for him. It might have been better to concede the national media to Obama for a week, and continue to campaign on a more regional basis.
Instead, we’ve had McCain on TV, blasting Obama for being wrong, wrong, wrong on the surge. “How’s the weather there in New Hampshire, Senator?” “Well, we’ve had some rain—it reminds me of how Sent. Obama’s claims about the Surge have turned out to be all wet. He was wrong on that, you know. And I was right!”
This kind of peevish, single-minded focus is hardly the stuff of great leadership.
What’s worse is that the McCain campaign has really started to sound a little unhinged. They put out an ad blaming Obama for the high price of gas. I am not kidding. I am not exaggerating. They blame Obama for the high price of gas. Desperate, much?
They also put out a three-minute YouTube video purporting to show how the media is fawning over Obama. You know, McCain has been a favorite of the media for a long time. One of the reasons he is the presumptive nominee is that his years of positive media coverage gave him the name recognition and good reputation to win primaries. It seems little silly for him to be complaining now about not getting enough media coverage.
Patently false ads, bitter denunciations, whining about the media. Not a great way to get people excited about your campaign, in my opinion.
This race is a long way from over. Heck, Obama’s trip is still not over. Things could happen to swing opinion one way or the other, but it appears to me the McCain campaign has made the worst of a bad situation.
Oh, and here’s a pertinent quote from Joe Klein of Time Magazine.
“John McCain said this today in Rochester, New Hampshire:
‘This is a clear choice that the American people have. I had the courage and the judgment to say I would rather lose a political campaign than lose a war. It seems to me that Obama would rather lose a war in order to win a political campaign.’
This is the ninth presidential campaign I've covered. I can't remember a more scurrilous statement by a major party candidate. It smacks of desperation. It renews questions about whether McCain has the right temperament for the presidency. How sad.”
This incoherent line of thought is, believe it or not, McCain’s strongest argument at the moment. It is a relatively strong point to note that Obama said the Surge would fail, when as it turns out, the Surge seems to be a factor in the improving security situation in Iraq. This success can be overstated—Americans, being human, tend to oversimplify and see their own actions as being the most important. The reasons for the improving situation in Iraq are many, and they include the Surge. Be that as it may, Obama’s call was wrong on this one. So he’s batting 800 instead of a 1,000 on Iraq. That’s still a better average than McCain or most Republicans can claim.
As Obama’s overseas tour continues, though, it seems to me that McCain has made a significant mistake. His campaign was obviously worried that Obama’s trip would suck up a huge amount of oxygen, and that people would forget about McCain. That’s a legitimate worry; the media are treating this as a Very Big Deal.
But in his efforts to remind people that this is a two-person campaign, McCain has resorted to shouting, jumping up and down, and waving his arms. It’s not a good tactic for him. It might have been better to concede the national media to Obama for a week, and continue to campaign on a more regional basis.
Instead, we’ve had McCain on TV, blasting Obama for being wrong, wrong, wrong on the surge. “How’s the weather there in New Hampshire, Senator?” “Well, we’ve had some rain—it reminds me of how Sent. Obama’s claims about the Surge have turned out to be all wet. He was wrong on that, you know. And I was right!”
This kind of peevish, single-minded focus is hardly the stuff of great leadership.
What’s worse is that the McCain campaign has really started to sound a little unhinged. They put out an ad blaming Obama for the high price of gas. I am not kidding. I am not exaggerating. They blame Obama for the high price of gas. Desperate, much?
They also put out a three-minute YouTube video purporting to show how the media is fawning over Obama. You know, McCain has been a favorite of the media for a long time. One of the reasons he is the presumptive nominee is that his years of positive media coverage gave him the name recognition and good reputation to win primaries. It seems little silly for him to be complaining now about not getting enough media coverage.
Patently false ads, bitter denunciations, whining about the media. Not a great way to get people excited about your campaign, in my opinion.
This race is a long way from over. Heck, Obama’s trip is still not over. Things could happen to swing opinion one way or the other, but it appears to me the McCain campaign has made the worst of a bad situation.
Oh, and here’s a pertinent quote from Joe Klein of Time Magazine.
“John McCain said this today in Rochester, New Hampshire:
‘This is a clear choice that the American people have. I had the courage and the judgment to say I would rather lose a political campaign than lose a war. It seems to me that Obama would rather lose a war in order to win a political campaign.’
This is the ninth presidential campaign I've covered. I can't remember a more scurrilous statement by a major party candidate. It smacks of desperation. It renews questions about whether McCain has the right temperament for the presidency. How sad.”
Thursday, July 17, 2008
Obama and the Evangelicals
Headline from US News and World Report:
Obama Campaign is Making Progress With Evangelical Voters
"They've researched where the votes are, and they've thrown away the old Democratic playbooks," says Brinson, who is among the evangelical leaders the Obama camp has reached out to. "Instead of just relying on a large number of urban votes, they're going to suburban areas and reaching out to a large number of conservatives."
I think this is great. It's about time someone on the Democratic side of politics went right after the church-going vote. Those folks tend to be more conservative, sure, but they're not all exactly the same. Despite what some on the left like to believe, evangelicals are not all marching in lock step. Some are going to be open to a centrist like Obama.
I like this approach that says, "We're not going to just try to win with 7 East Coast States and three West Coast states and try to pick up a few in the middle." If the Dems want to really lead this country, they are going to have to be a national party. They are going to have to have support outside the traditional strongholds. And Obama seems to get that.
The article ends by asking whether there are risks: whether Obama's outreach to the evangelicals will alienate traditional Dem voters. We've already seen some backlash over his supposed "change" in positions, which have been largely cases of media hype and selective memory. But let me put the question to my readers:
What do you think of Obama's efforts to win evangelical votes?
Obama Campaign is Making Progress With Evangelical Voters
"They've researched where the votes are, and they've thrown away the old Democratic playbooks," says Brinson, who is among the evangelical leaders the Obama camp has reached out to. "Instead of just relying on a large number of urban votes, they're going to suburban areas and reaching out to a large number of conservatives."
I think this is great. It's about time someone on the Democratic side of politics went right after the church-going vote. Those folks tend to be more conservative, sure, but they're not all exactly the same. Despite what some on the left like to believe, evangelicals are not all marching in lock step. Some are going to be open to a centrist like Obama.
I like this approach that says, "We're not going to just try to win with 7 East Coast States and three West Coast states and try to pick up a few in the middle." If the Dems want to really lead this country, they are going to have to be a national party. They are going to have to have support outside the traditional strongholds. And Obama seems to get that.
The article ends by asking whether there are risks: whether Obama's outreach to the evangelicals will alienate traditional Dem voters. We've already seen some backlash over his supposed "change" in positions, which have been largely cases of media hype and selective memory. But let me put the question to my readers:
What do you think of Obama's efforts to win evangelical votes?
Monday, July 07, 2008
Wall-E
"While the real-life grown-ups on TV were again rebooting Vietnam, the kids at “Wall-E” were in deep contemplation of a world in peril — and of the future that is theirs to make what they will of it. Compare any 10 minutes of the movie with 10 minutes of any cable-news channel, and you’ll soon be asking: Exactly who are the adults in our country and who are the cartoon characters?"
Frank Rich pretty much hits it out of the park with his column that skillfully uses an animated children's movie to illustrate what's wrong with our political process.
By the way, I saw Wall-E a few days ago and enjoyed it a lot. I'm not sure it's quite as spectacularly good as some of the reviews suggest, but it is very enjoyable, and the social/environmental commentary is on target and not heavy handed at all. It's hard to focus sometimes when your 2-year old is complaining of being "caird" and your five-year old is consuming a bag of popcorn nearly as big as he is, so I think I'll need to watch it again to really catch everything. But I recommend it.
Frank Rich pretty much hits it out of the park with his column that skillfully uses an animated children's movie to illustrate what's wrong with our political process.
By the way, I saw Wall-E a few days ago and enjoyed it a lot. I'm not sure it's quite as spectacularly good as some of the reviews suggest, but it is very enjoyable, and the social/environmental commentary is on target and not heavy handed at all. It's hard to focus sometimes when your 2-year old is complaining of being "caird" and your five-year old is consuming a bag of popcorn nearly as big as he is, so I think I'll need to watch it again to really catch everything. But I recommend it.
Wednesday, July 02, 2008
Change You Can Be Comfortable With
Doesn’t have much zip to it, does it?
But that could well be the unofficial theme of the Obama campaign these days.
Since become the presumptive nominee, Sen. Obama has carefully been moving back to the middle, making statements and policy proposals that are aimed to appeal to—and perhaps reassure—independents and more-conservative Democrats. This is nothing new at all, we see it pretty much every four years. And Sen. McCain made a similar move after he wrapped up his nomination; going on a poverty tour with a “Message: I Care” flavor to show Americans that compassionate conservatism was not dead. (Message: nice try.)
But while McCain is still exhibiting some minor symptoms of schizophrenia with his efforts to win over both independents AND the Republican base, Obama has morphed into Mr. Moderate, with a healthy helping of Bipartisan to go.
Obama has weighed in on the recent Supreme Court ruling on gun control by more or less agreeing that citizens have an individual right to bear arms. It’s not going to save him from the $40 million “Obama’s coming for your guns” attack ad campaign that the NRA has planned, but it might help him convince a few independents that he’s not as big a liberal as the NRA fanatics say he is. (My apologies to NRA members. But let’s be honest. The NRA is pretty out there at times.)
Obama has also recently changed his position on the FISA crimes that the current administration and telecom companies want immunity for. He’s taking a very middle-of-the-road stance here, and he’s right in step with most congressional Democrats at this point. But as far as I can tell from this rather complicated issue, the Dems are kind of caving on this one. We probably won’t know for sure how illegal the Bush Administration’s actions were until they’re out of office, but they really seemed to bend the laws here past the breaking point. “Bygones!” says Obama and the Dem leadership. Big of them.
And it’s been kind of sad watching Obama try to convince people that he doesn’t hate America. God knows he’s in a tough position there. I’ve seen some of the emails, and it is not pretty. So if he feels the need to wear a flag pin and make a speech on patriotism, all I can do is wish him luck. Some people are determined to find fault no matter what, and the patriotism issue gives them an excuse because it can be so subjective. “He didn’t say the Pledge LOUD enough!”
And then there’s the Wes Clark thing. I think Clark’s comments were unfortunate, but not scandalous. Yes, in fact, being a POW is not in itself a qualification for being Commander in Chief, but why even make that statement? Why give the McCain an excuse to act outraged and more patriotic-than-thou on the same day Obama is giving his speech dealing with that subject? It was a boneheaded move. And though many bloggers are mad at Obama for condemning Clark’s statement, the fact is it’s a huge mistake to start having arguments about Vietnam AGAIN, after we are all so sick of anything that remotely resembles Swiftboating.
If anything, Obama’s condemnation of Clark fits with his pledge to run a different kind of campaign and avoid the personal attacks and distractions. I honestly don’t think Clark was trying to make a personal attack on McCain, but it sounded petty.
Obama’s embrace of faith-based programs is also interesting, although I need to hear more details to comment on that at any length.
But all in all, Obama’s not looking like an agent of radical change as we enter the national stage of this campaign, and I think that’s both to be expected and appropriate. The county is hungry for change, but too much change is scary. Obama’s trying to find a balance. It’s a bit of a tightrope walk, but that’s what all presidential candidates do to some extent.
But that could well be the unofficial theme of the Obama campaign these days.
Since become the presumptive nominee, Sen. Obama has carefully been moving back to the middle, making statements and policy proposals that are aimed to appeal to—and perhaps reassure—independents and more-conservative Democrats. This is nothing new at all, we see it pretty much every four years. And Sen. McCain made a similar move after he wrapped up his nomination; going on a poverty tour with a “Message: I Care” flavor to show Americans that compassionate conservatism was not dead. (Message: nice try.)
But while McCain is still exhibiting some minor symptoms of schizophrenia with his efforts to win over both independents AND the Republican base, Obama has morphed into Mr. Moderate, with a healthy helping of Bipartisan to go.
Obama has weighed in on the recent Supreme Court ruling on gun control by more or less agreeing that citizens have an individual right to bear arms. It’s not going to save him from the $40 million “Obama’s coming for your guns” attack ad campaign that the NRA has planned, but it might help him convince a few independents that he’s not as big a liberal as the NRA fanatics say he is. (My apologies to NRA members. But let’s be honest. The NRA is pretty out there at times.)
Obama has also recently changed his position on the FISA crimes that the current administration and telecom companies want immunity for. He’s taking a very middle-of-the-road stance here, and he’s right in step with most congressional Democrats at this point. But as far as I can tell from this rather complicated issue, the Dems are kind of caving on this one. We probably won’t know for sure how illegal the Bush Administration’s actions were until they’re out of office, but they really seemed to bend the laws here past the breaking point. “Bygones!” says Obama and the Dem leadership. Big of them.
And it’s been kind of sad watching Obama try to convince people that he doesn’t hate America. God knows he’s in a tough position there. I’ve seen some of the emails, and it is not pretty. So if he feels the need to wear a flag pin and make a speech on patriotism, all I can do is wish him luck. Some people are determined to find fault no matter what, and the patriotism issue gives them an excuse because it can be so subjective. “He didn’t say the Pledge LOUD enough!”
And then there’s the Wes Clark thing. I think Clark’s comments were unfortunate, but not scandalous. Yes, in fact, being a POW is not in itself a qualification for being Commander in Chief, but why even make that statement? Why give the McCain an excuse to act outraged and more patriotic-than-thou on the same day Obama is giving his speech dealing with that subject? It was a boneheaded move. And though many bloggers are mad at Obama for condemning Clark’s statement, the fact is it’s a huge mistake to start having arguments about Vietnam AGAIN, after we are all so sick of anything that remotely resembles Swiftboating.
If anything, Obama’s condemnation of Clark fits with his pledge to run a different kind of campaign and avoid the personal attacks and distractions. I honestly don’t think Clark was trying to make a personal attack on McCain, but it sounded petty.
Obama’s embrace of faith-based programs is also interesting, although I need to hear more details to comment on that at any length.
But all in all, Obama’s not looking like an agent of radical change as we enter the national stage of this campaign, and I think that’s both to be expected and appropriate. The county is hungry for change, but too much change is scary. Obama’s trying to find a balance. It’s a bit of a tightrope walk, but that’s what all presidential candidates do to some extent.
Thursday, June 05, 2008
Pundit Heaven
The announcement that Sen. Hillary Clinton will end her campaign Saturday, along with Sen. Obama's wrapping up the needed delegates for the nomination, has produced a deluge of "how he won"/"how she lost" post mortems.
Two that gave me a lot of good information were Chris Cillizza's blog and Sabato's Crystal Ball blog. The Cillizza [horrible misspelling corrected, sorry!] piece is a good rundown of the strategies and philosophical approach of Obama's campaign, while the Sabato piece (written by Justin Sizemore) is full of crunchy goodness such as charts, graphs and plenty of numbers. Both are good reads and very informative.
There's been some talk in the comments about the likelihood of Obama picking Clinton as a running mate. I would say the chances are extremely slim. Obama just named a three-person team to manage the selection process, which I take as a sign he's going to be very deliberative about this and let the "Dream Ticket" talk die down a bit. Hopefully it will, because it's hard to imagine Sen. Clinton being a good fit. The Clintons of course come as a matched set, and they tend to overshadow anyone else in the room. Obama doesn't need that. I see the appeal of the Obama/Clinton ticket, but I also see the risks, and they really look overwhelming to me. Just my 2¢.
Two that gave me a lot of good information were Chris Cillizza's blog and Sabato's Crystal Ball blog. The Cillizza [horrible misspelling corrected, sorry!] piece is a good rundown of the strategies and philosophical approach of Obama's campaign, while the Sabato piece (written by Justin Sizemore) is full of crunchy goodness such as charts, graphs and plenty of numbers. Both are good reads and very informative.
There's been some talk in the comments about the likelihood of Obama picking Clinton as a running mate. I would say the chances are extremely slim. Obama just named a three-person team to manage the selection process, which I take as a sign he's going to be very deliberative about this and let the "Dream Ticket" talk die down a bit. Hopefully it will, because it's hard to imagine Sen. Clinton being a good fit. The Clintons of course come as a matched set, and they tend to overshadow anyone else in the room. Obama doesn't need that. I see the appeal of the Obama/Clinton ticket, but I also see the risks, and they really look overwhelming to me. Just my 2¢.
Garbage Time and Trash Talking
I hesitate to raise this point. Supporters of Sen. Clinton have taken her loss very hard, and they have every right to feel that she deserves respect and credit for the incredible race she ran. I was very impressed by how she finished so strong in the last month or so.
But I do think this talk of "winning the popular vote" is a bit disingenuous. By the most fair count (including all caucus state estimates and excluding Michigan, which was not a fair election by any stretch of the imagination), Obama won the popular vote, albeit narrowly. Still, there's nothing wrong with Clinton supporters being proud of her big wins at the very end--IF they also acknowledge the reality that Obama had this thing wrapped up some time ago. That reality seems a little hard to grasp for some.
There's an expression in sports which I think applies here. "Garbage Time" is often referred to in basketball games and football games as a time in the game where the outcome is not in doubt, but the winning team is just running out the clock, while the losing team is doing everything they can to make the score respectable, or pull off a miracle win.
Sound familiar?
(Of course I don't mean to imply that any candidate or state or voting group is garbage. Let's make that clear.)
But In the last month of the campaign, Obama was transitioning to the general election, engaging the McCain team on a series of issues and going to swing states to address voter concerns there. Sen. Clinton, on the other hand, was still campaigning full bore in the final states. Obama could have decided to continue to fully contest the primaries and leave the national stuff 'till later, but I think he was right to move on. If Obama had really contested every state, those popular vote totals would be different. Not that it matters much. But it's a little annoying that even at the end, Clinton was making that "we won the popular vote" claim. It's not true, and even if you accept the Clinton campaign's fuzzy math, it would only be true because of garbage time.
Now that I've offended the few (any?) Clinton supporters who read this blog, I'll move on to John McCain's speech Tuesday night.
Hooo boy, that did not look good. Forget the comparison with the dynamic Obama or the impassioned Clinton, just watch the thing for what it is. An extremely uncomfortable man giving a leaden, awkward speech. The weird thing is, I don't believe the speech was badly written. McCain just seemed incapable of delivering it in a convincing manner. The refrain "That's not change we can believe in," should have been a rallying cry, a phrase with some anger or at least determination behind it. McCain treated it like a punch line in a weak joke, plastering on fake smile every time he repeated the line. I thought maybe he was trying to go for a Reagan-esque, "there you go again," genial feel; but it totally didn't fit the material.
McCain has been trying to talk tough in the early part of this national campaign, trying to make Obama look young and naive, trying to raise fears of appeasement or weakness. But if you're going to trash talk, you better sound like your heart is in it. Because it wasn't Obama who looked weak Tuesday night.
But I do think this talk of "winning the popular vote" is a bit disingenuous. By the most fair count (including all caucus state estimates and excluding Michigan, which was not a fair election by any stretch of the imagination), Obama won the popular vote, albeit narrowly. Still, there's nothing wrong with Clinton supporters being proud of her big wins at the very end--IF they also acknowledge the reality that Obama had this thing wrapped up some time ago. That reality seems a little hard to grasp for some.
There's an expression in sports which I think applies here. "Garbage Time" is often referred to in basketball games and football games as a time in the game where the outcome is not in doubt, but the winning team is just running out the clock, while the losing team is doing everything they can to make the score respectable, or pull off a miracle win.
Sound familiar?
(Of course I don't mean to imply that any candidate or state or voting group is garbage. Let's make that clear.)
But In the last month of the campaign, Obama was transitioning to the general election, engaging the McCain team on a series of issues and going to swing states to address voter concerns there. Sen. Clinton, on the other hand, was still campaigning full bore in the final states. Obama could have decided to continue to fully contest the primaries and leave the national stuff 'till later, but I think he was right to move on. If Obama had really contested every state, those popular vote totals would be different. Not that it matters much. But it's a little annoying that even at the end, Clinton was making that "we won the popular vote" claim. It's not true, and even if you accept the Clinton campaign's fuzzy math, it would only be true because of garbage time.
Now that I've offended the few (any?) Clinton supporters who read this blog, I'll move on to John McCain's speech Tuesday night.
Hooo boy, that did not look good. Forget the comparison with the dynamic Obama or the impassioned Clinton, just watch the thing for what it is. An extremely uncomfortable man giving a leaden, awkward speech. The weird thing is, I don't believe the speech was badly written. McCain just seemed incapable of delivering it in a convincing manner. The refrain "That's not change we can believe in," should have been a rallying cry, a phrase with some anger or at least determination behind it. McCain treated it like a punch line in a weak joke, plastering on fake smile every time he repeated the line. I thought maybe he was trying to go for a Reagan-esque, "there you go again," genial feel; but it totally didn't fit the material.
McCain has been trying to talk tough in the early part of this national campaign, trying to make Obama look young and naive, trying to raise fears of appeasement or weakness. But if you're going to trash talk, you better sound like your heart is in it. Because it wasn't Obama who looked weak Tuesday night.
Tuesday, June 03, 2008
The End of the Road
Remarkable. Extraordinary. Unprecedented.
Those are the words that come to mind when I think of the primary campaigns of Sens. Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama. This has been a riveting, hard-fought race from the first caucuses in Iowa to the moment the final polls close tonight in Montana.
The Republican side was interesting in its own way, with a very colorful cast of characters and plenty of interesting issues to work out. I agree with the conventional wisdom that almost despite itself, the Republican party is nominating the candidate with the best chance of winning. Whether the base can really get behind McCain remains to be seen. I was visiting some conservative relatives recently and there was very little enthusiasm for McCain. I sense they will vote for him, but they are not excited.
But the D side is excited. Maybe a little too much so in some cases. I’ve been checking out some of the pro-Clinton blogs lately and boy, talk about some raw nerves. They are not happy with the media, with Obama supporters, and in some cases, with Obama himself. I keep hearing him say nice things about Clinton, but many of these HRC supporters are having none of it. They are, to borrow a word, bitter. I believe that will change.
But overall, this has been an historic primary on the Dem side, and both candidates have run admirable campaigns. Both have stumbled at times, but they both showed real resilience and strength of character. That’s just my take, but I don’t think anyone can disagree that this has been one for the history books.
I’ve felt for some time that Clinton simply was not going to win; that it was a case of too little too late. And I think that’s playing out about as expected. But give her credit for fighting to the last. We can argue about whether it’s good for the party or divisive, but the fact is she ended up coming very close, which is a credit to her. And she almost certainly will concede in the next few days, which gives Obama plenty of time to unite the party.
An African American is going to be the nominee for President from the Democratic party in 2008. And I would say he has at least an even shot of winning the general election in the fall. This is a good day for our country.
Prediction:
South Dakota: Obama 52, Clinton 48
Montana: Obama 58, Clinton 42
(Sorry I missed Puerto Rico — I was traveling and just couldn’t get something written.)
Those are the words that come to mind when I think of the primary campaigns of Sens. Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama. This has been a riveting, hard-fought race from the first caucuses in Iowa to the moment the final polls close tonight in Montana.
The Republican side was interesting in its own way, with a very colorful cast of characters and plenty of interesting issues to work out. I agree with the conventional wisdom that almost despite itself, the Republican party is nominating the candidate with the best chance of winning. Whether the base can really get behind McCain remains to be seen. I was visiting some conservative relatives recently and there was very little enthusiasm for McCain. I sense they will vote for him, but they are not excited.
But the D side is excited. Maybe a little too much so in some cases. I’ve been checking out some of the pro-Clinton blogs lately and boy, talk about some raw nerves. They are not happy with the media, with Obama supporters, and in some cases, with Obama himself. I keep hearing him say nice things about Clinton, but many of these HRC supporters are having none of it. They are, to borrow a word, bitter. I believe that will change.
But overall, this has been an historic primary on the Dem side, and both candidates have run admirable campaigns. Both have stumbled at times, but they both showed real resilience and strength of character. That’s just my take, but I don’t think anyone can disagree that this has been one for the history books.
I’ve felt for some time that Clinton simply was not going to win; that it was a case of too little too late. And I think that’s playing out about as expected. But give her credit for fighting to the last. We can argue about whether it’s good for the party or divisive, but the fact is she ended up coming very close, which is a credit to her. And she almost certainly will concede in the next few days, which gives Obama plenty of time to unite the party.
An African American is going to be the nominee for President from the Democratic party in 2008. And I would say he has at least an even shot of winning the general election in the fall. This is a good day for our country.
Prediction:
South Dakota: Obama 52, Clinton 48
Montana: Obama 58, Clinton 42
(Sorry I missed Puerto Rico — I was traveling and just couldn’t get something written.)
Tuesday, May 20, 2008
Confession: I Only Watch CNN for the Maps
That, and Donna Brazile. Donna rocks.
So I'll probably be up late tonight, watching John King working the maps; pinching, squeezing, pushing ... ugh, I just totally grossed myself out.
I propose a drinking game for tonight's primary results: every time King stumbles over the name of a county in Oregon, take a drink. And if you don't think that will give you enough chances, here's a partial list: Clackamas, Multnomah, Wallowa, Deschutes (bless you!), Yamhill, Tillamook, and ... Clatsop!
("My friends they come around, say Clatsop Clatsop Clatsop Clatsop...")
But what to do about Kentucky? If we take a drink every time they mention working class white voters, we'll all be unconscious before the Oregon polls even close. Or whatever they do up there in their elitist, vote-by-mail state. What's with you, Oregon? Why can't you have messed-up voting machines and ballot shortages like all the other states?
I suggest a drink every time the phrase "Florida and Michigan" comes up during the Kentucky returns. We'll hear that a lot, but not so much that we'll wake up thinking Larry King carried 64 percent of the suspender vote in Malheur County.
prediction:
Kentucky - Clinton 62, Obama 30, Edwards 5, Bill Monroe 3
Oregon - Obama 60, Clinton 39
So I'll probably be up late tonight, watching John King working the maps; pinching, squeezing, pushing ... ugh, I just totally grossed myself out.
I propose a drinking game for tonight's primary results: every time King stumbles over the name of a county in Oregon, take a drink. And if you don't think that will give you enough chances, here's a partial list: Clackamas, Multnomah, Wallowa, Deschutes (bless you!), Yamhill, Tillamook, and ... Clatsop!
("My friends they come around, say Clatsop Clatsop Clatsop Clatsop...")
But what to do about Kentucky? If we take a drink every time they mention working class white voters, we'll all be unconscious before the Oregon polls even close. Or whatever they do up there in their elitist, vote-by-mail state. What's with you, Oregon? Why can't you have messed-up voting machines and ballot shortages like all the other states?
I suggest a drink every time the phrase "Florida and Michigan" comes up during the Kentucky returns. We'll hear that a lot, but not so much that we'll wake up thinking Larry King carried 64 percent of the suspender vote in Malheur County.
prediction:
Kentucky - Clinton 62, Obama 30, Edwards 5, Bill Monroe 3
Oregon - Obama 60, Clinton 39
Monday, May 19, 2008
Obama's terrible problem with white voters
Sorry for the snark. One of my pet peeves has been the tendency for media to overplay the supposed "white-voter-gap" for Obama. Here in Minnesota, Obama won decisively. Some states he's done better with whites, some worse, but it is much more complicated than "Obama does/does not appeal to white voters." It has a lot to do with geography and culture, and sure, racial attitudes play a role, but Obama has shown he can appeal across a very broad spectrum of voters.
Anyhow, the pics from the Portland rally (75,000 people) are impressive no matter how you look at them.
Thursday, May 15, 2008
VEEP VEEP!
Some intriguing chatter about vice presidential picks lately. I saw a story that says Mike Huckabee is now at the top of McCain’s short list. One thing about McCain, he is not dumb. Huckabee may not be from a swing state (I think Arkansas will be in the R column in any election not featuring a Clinton on the ticket), but he can deliver the very key evangelical vote, especially in states like Florida and Ohio.
Huckabee has some truly nutty ideas and will turn some off with his very religious politics, but those voters are likely not to vote R anyhow. What he does bring is a lot of star power and likeability to the ticket. And he is not, as McCain has said about himself, “old as dirt.”
I just remember when Huck said the Wal Mart voters were the wind beneath his wings. Brilliant! That guy can connect with those voters, and bring them out, in a way that a Pawlenty or a Romney never would. Huckabee would be a great choice for VP.
And then there is the much-talked-about Obama/Clinton ticket. Some are now saying that if Sen. Clinton wants it, Obama will have to give her the job because she has so many delegates and so much support. But I can really see strong arguments both ways. Obama has been criticizing Clinton as part of the problem in Washington; it’s going to be tough to turn around and pick her as VP. And who wants Bill Clinton roaming the White House, bored, looking for trouble?? Not BO, I would bet.
But still. Hillary Clinton, like Huckabee, has proven to be a formidable campaigner who appeals to working class people (and not just whites; Latinos are also a very strong group for her). IF the two could get along, and IF their staffs didn’t start sniping at each other and IF they could ship Bill off to Tahiti or something, this matchup could really generate some excitement. But those are big ifs, don’t you think?
So what's your opinion? Any favorites for VP?
Oh, and I found this; The Hill went to every senator and asked if they’d be interested in the VP slot. Some of the replies are pretty funny: Joe Lieberman said, “I already have the T-shirt.” Larry Craig (of all people) also had a good response: “I would say, ‘No, Hillary.’”
Huckabee has some truly nutty ideas and will turn some off with his very religious politics, but those voters are likely not to vote R anyhow. What he does bring is a lot of star power and likeability to the ticket. And he is not, as McCain has said about himself, “old as dirt.”
I just remember when Huck said the Wal Mart voters were the wind beneath his wings. Brilliant! That guy can connect with those voters, and bring them out, in a way that a Pawlenty or a Romney never would. Huckabee would be a great choice for VP.
And then there is the much-talked-about Obama/Clinton ticket. Some are now saying that if Sen. Clinton wants it, Obama will have to give her the job because she has so many delegates and so much support. But I can really see strong arguments both ways. Obama has been criticizing Clinton as part of the problem in Washington; it’s going to be tough to turn around and pick her as VP. And who wants Bill Clinton roaming the White House, bored, looking for trouble?? Not BO, I would bet.
But still. Hillary Clinton, like Huckabee, has proven to be a formidable campaigner who appeals to working class people (and not just whites; Latinos are also a very strong group for her). IF the two could get along, and IF their staffs didn’t start sniping at each other and IF they could ship Bill off to Tahiti or something, this matchup could really generate some excitement. But those are big ifs, don’t you think?
So what's your opinion? Any favorites for VP?
Oh, and I found this; The Hill went to every senator and asked if they’d be interested in the VP slot. Some of the replies are pretty funny: Joe Lieberman said, “I already have the T-shirt.” Larry Craig (of all people) also had a good response: “I would say, ‘No, Hillary.’”
Tuesday, May 13, 2008
Please, no more "Country Roads" references...
Ok, West Virginia is the site of a primary today. Sen. Clinton will win it by a very large margin, and I am so looking forward to the ensuing discussion of What It All Means.
Look, Clinton clearly wrote some states off, and Obama is writing this one off. So the big win will not mean much. It won't make a big dent in the delegate lead and probably not in the popular vote totals.
Some are talking about the possibility of racism hurting Obama in states like West Virginia. I suppose it's possible that in the fall election this could shave a couple of points off of Obama's totals in some states. But I just don't think it's going to have a big impact overall. Time will tell.
Prediction: Clinton 60, Obama 40.
Look, Clinton clearly wrote some states off, and Obama is writing this one off. So the big win will not mean much. It won't make a big dent in the delegate lead and probably not in the popular vote totals.
Some are talking about the possibility of racism hurting Obama in states like West Virginia. I suppose it's possible that in the fall election this could shave a couple of points off of Obama's totals in some states. But I just don't think it's going to have a big impact overall. Time will tell.
Prediction: Clinton 60, Obama 40.
Wednesday, May 07, 2008
The End in Sight
Well, that was fun.
A memorable night in American politics; we went to bed not knowing the winner of the Indiana primary. But the overall outcome was clear: Sen. Obama had regained the momentum toward the nomination and Sen. Clinton is running on fumes ... to use a gasoline reference, which seems timely.
Congratulations to all who participated in these two primaries, regardless of what candidate they voted for. They have a right to feel proud of their contributions to our democratic process.
Lots of interesting things on the CNN interactive map.
Much has been made of the so-called racial divide amongst voters, but look how Obama did in nearly all-white counties like Tipton, Carroll, Vanderburgh (where Evansville is): scoring in the 40s, even the high 40s is not bad at all. It's counties like these that kept the totals close enough to give Obama an opportunity to win with results from the big urban counties like Marion and Lake. In the end, he fell just short, but it was much closer than almost anyone predicted (especially me.) And 61-39 Obama in Hamilton County?? That's a surprise.
Another thing that jumped out at me were the numbers on the Republican side. Huckabee won 10 percent of the vote. Ron Paul won 8 percent. Mitt Romney (remember him? The hair guy! No, not Edwards, the REPUBLICAN hair guy!) won 5 percent.
Are you kidding me? A guy that has been out of the race for months, who has already endorsed McCain and is fishing for a VP nod, still pulls in 5 percent? The total Republican vote opposing the anointed candidate who has the entire R establishment behind him and no one campaigning against him is * over * 20 * percent?!?
Something's not right with that picture. But please, go on and talk about how the Democrats are divided.
A memorable night in American politics; we went to bed not knowing the winner of the Indiana primary. But the overall outcome was clear: Sen. Obama had regained the momentum toward the nomination and Sen. Clinton is running on fumes ... to use a gasoline reference, which seems timely.
Congratulations to all who participated in these two primaries, regardless of what candidate they voted for. They have a right to feel proud of their contributions to our democratic process.
Lots of interesting things on the CNN interactive map.
Much has been made of the so-called racial divide amongst voters, but look how Obama did in nearly all-white counties like Tipton, Carroll, Vanderburgh (where Evansville is): scoring in the 40s, even the high 40s is not bad at all. It's counties like these that kept the totals close enough to give Obama an opportunity to win with results from the big urban counties like Marion and Lake. In the end, he fell just short, but it was much closer than almost anyone predicted (especially me.) And 61-39 Obama in Hamilton County?? That's a surprise.
Another thing that jumped out at me were the numbers on the Republican side. Huckabee won 10 percent of the vote. Ron Paul won 8 percent. Mitt Romney (remember him? The hair guy! No, not Edwards, the REPUBLICAN hair guy!) won 5 percent.
Are you kidding me? A guy that has been out of the race for months, who has already endorsed McCain and is fishing for a VP nod, still pulls in 5 percent? The total Republican vote opposing the anointed candidate who has the entire R establishment behind him and no one campaigning against him is * over * 20 * percent?!?
Something's not right with that picture. But please, go on and talk about how the Democrats are divided.
Tuesday, May 06, 2008
A Primary That Matters
For both NC and IN, this is the biggest political event in recent memory, perhaps the biggest primary election ever for two states that vote so late in the season. And there are a lot of blogs and media sites covering it, so we all can share the excitement at least a little.
Here's something from the Indianapolis Star's political blog; a Top Ten Moments of the 08 Primary. My favorite entries:
"3. Obama playing a game of three-on-three basketball in Kokomo, erasing any doubts about his playing ability.
2. Clinton drinking a shot of whiskey at a pizza pub in Crown Point, erasing any doubts about her drinking ability."
If you haven't already, get out and vote!*
http://blogs.indystar.com/politics/
(*applicable to IN and NC residents only. For IN residents,
some restrictions apply.
Here's something from the Indianapolis Star's political blog; a Top Ten Moments of the 08 Primary. My favorite entries:
"3. Obama playing a game of three-on-three basketball in Kokomo, erasing any doubts about his playing ability.
2. Clinton drinking a shot of whiskey at a pizza pub in Crown Point, erasing any doubts about her drinking ability."
If you haven't already, get out and vote!*
http://blogs.indystar.com/politics/
(*applicable to IN and NC residents only. For IN residents,
some restrictions apply.
Monday, May 05, 2008
Indiana and North Carolina
The consensus is that Sen. Clinton will win Indiana and Sen. Obama will win North Carolina.
My feeling is that it's a relief to see the candidates discussing something other than Rev. Wright. Even thought the main topic for the last week has been Clinton's ill-advised gas tax holiday, at least it's legitimate policy disagreement, rather than guilt-by-association and overhyped controversy.
One of the blogs I've read says my old stomping grounds of Kokomo and Howard County will be a "bellweather" region, so whoever wins there will win the state, by that reasoning. And I see Obama visited an old farmstead near Tipton, where some ancestors of his lived--also within spitting distance of some of my relatives.
I think the Wright thing damaged Obama a little too much for him to come back from in Indiana, but this was always a state in which I would've expected him to have a tough time. If anything, I am surprised by how receptive Hoosiers have been to Obama. Some are saying it will be close in IN, but I'm expecting a respectable double digit win for Clinton that will nonetheless not be a blowout and not give her a big delegate advantage.
In North Carolina, I expect an Obama win of anywhere from 5 to 20 points. Where he ends up in that range will have a big impact on how the race proceeds. A big win would mean a significant delegate and popular vote advantage, that would make Clinton's road a lot tougher. A close win for Obama and Clinton can claim momementum, blah blah blah. She still can't win, probably, but we'll certainly be in for some furious campaigning for the last few states.
A Clinton win in NC would be, in her words, a game-changer.
Predictions
Indiana: 56 Clinton, 44 Obama
North Carolina: 54 Obama, 46 Clinton
My feeling is that it's a relief to see the candidates discussing something other than Rev. Wright. Even thought the main topic for the last week has been Clinton's ill-advised gas tax holiday, at least it's legitimate policy disagreement, rather than guilt-by-association and overhyped controversy.
One of the blogs I've read says my old stomping grounds of Kokomo and Howard County will be a "bellweather" region, so whoever wins there will win the state, by that reasoning. And I see Obama visited an old farmstead near Tipton, where some ancestors of his lived--also within spitting distance of some of my relatives.
I think the Wright thing damaged Obama a little too much for him to come back from in Indiana, but this was always a state in which I would've expected him to have a tough time. If anything, I am surprised by how receptive Hoosiers have been to Obama. Some are saying it will be close in IN, but I'm expecting a respectable double digit win for Clinton that will nonetheless not be a blowout and not give her a big delegate advantage.
In North Carolina, I expect an Obama win of anywhere from 5 to 20 points. Where he ends up in that range will have a big impact on how the race proceeds. A big win would mean a significant delegate and popular vote advantage, that would make Clinton's road a lot tougher. A close win for Obama and Clinton can claim momementum, blah blah blah. She still can't win, probably, but we'll certainly be in for some furious campaigning for the last few states.
A Clinton win in NC would be, in her words, a game-changer.
Predictions
Indiana: 56 Clinton, 44 Obama
North Carolina: 54 Obama, 46 Clinton
Friday, May 02, 2008
Email From Indiana
Got an email recently from an Indiana voter with some questions on the two Dem candidates. This voter was trying to make a decision and asked questions about where the candidates stood on 1) alternate fuel sources, 2) mortgage crisis, and 3) the Iraq war.
With some minor modifications, I’m pasting my reply below. I am very interested in the IN primary and have been following it closely. With the tough time that Obama has had recently, I expect Clinton to be the choice for Hoosiers (that seems so weird to say!!) but there is still a chance Obama could surprise there, or that it could at least be close.
Anyhow, I would be VERY interested to hear from other Hoosiers or North Carolina residents on what the primary campaigns have been like there and any thoughts they may have on the candidates. Most of you have my email address, or you can leave comments here…
So, what follows is my reply:
I'll start by saying both candidates are, in my opinion, very well qualified and will probably bring some good people in to work on these problems. Sen. Clinton is very smart and I think she would do a great job. I just like Obama better, I think he can do a better job of bringing people together, creating consensus, improving our standing in the world, etc. He's had to endure a lot of attacks and controversies in the past month from the media and his loose-cannon ex-pastor, but he's continued to keep his cool and keep pushing forward, and I think that's a good sign.
Clinton, in my opinion, is kind of an old-school Democratic who is not as likely to be innovative and not as likely to build consensus. I could be wrong. But that's how I see it.
Specifically on the questions you raised:
The energy question is not an area I'm an expert in. However, I do know Obama went to Detroit and told the automakers point-blank that they needed to make more efficient cars with higher mileage standards. I'm sure Clinton supports that in principle too. If we look at Bill Clinton's term, we see a President who was OK on the environment, did some good things as far as designating national parks, etc., but didn't really make the environment a top issue. He also didn't do anything too memorable in the area of energy policy. (At least not that I remember.)
I think the next president is going to have to make the environment and energy (the two are closely linked of course) a top priority. That means fighting some very powerful interests. I believe Obama is better positioned to do that. He makes the claim that he doesn't take money from lobbyists, which is true, with a caveat—he has taken individual contributions from people with who work for oil companies--as opposed to the firms that lobby for oil companies. But he is in general not as beholden to special interests as Clinton and McCain would be.
In the area of financial issues/home mortgage crisis, I think both candidates have good ideas on some possible solutions and would be a lot more proactive than the current administration, or McCain. The whole issue is an example of why free markets are not a panacea. People are losing their homes and their savings; it's not enough to stand back and "let the market work." Because sometimes it doesn't. My guess is that Obama, as a former community organizer, would have a much better feel for how these problems affect working people. But that's just a guess.
On the war in Iraq. Both Dem. Senators now oppose it, both are committed to bringing troops home as quickly as possible while still doing it in an orderly fashion, both say they want to emphasize diplomacy and minimize any upheaval caused by a US withdrawal. Both may be underplaying the difficulty of doing that. That war is a horrific mess, and anything we do to end our involvement is going to come with some very big risks. The only worse thing than doing something, though, is doing nothing and letting the anti-American hatred continue to fester there and in other parts of the Middle East. That's just my opinion, of course.
So both have pledged similar strategies. But they come from different backgrounds and will likely have different approaches overall in the foreign policy area. Clinton has shown herself to be a mainstream, maybe even slightly conservative Democrat when it comes to foreign policy. In my opinion, she has made a classic Clintonian calculation that voters see Dems as "weak" on military and foreign policy matters, so she has to appear more conservative to counter that. In a way, that's smart. And I don't think it's even as calculating as it sounds—many old-school Dems are pretty conservative when it comes to foreign policy. Bill Clinton's foreign policy was not really significantly different than that of previous administrations.
Obama, I believe, is charting a slightly different course, with a big emphasis on diplomacy and multi-lateral cooperation. I think we do need to improve our image overseas, and nothing would send a stronger signal that we are going to re-connect with the world than to elect an African American with a funny name. Now, some voters are not particularly interested in the idea that America has to get along with other countries; they prefer being the superpower and throwing our weight around. I don't think that's possible anymore, and it certainly hasn't worked out well for us in the past 7 years.
Who will do a better job of getting us out of Iraq? I don't know. I think Obama will do more to improve our image and bring other nations to the table to work on the problem, but can he be tough, I think is the question that skeptics will ask. Aside from the point that "being tough" may be part of our problem, I can't answer the question. We all have to take our own measure of the man.
I hope that helps. I believe either candidate is deserving of your vote.
With some minor modifications, I’m pasting my reply below. I am very interested in the IN primary and have been following it closely. With the tough time that Obama has had recently, I expect Clinton to be the choice for Hoosiers (that seems so weird to say!!) but there is still a chance Obama could surprise there, or that it could at least be close.
Anyhow, I would be VERY interested to hear from other Hoosiers or North Carolina residents on what the primary campaigns have been like there and any thoughts they may have on the candidates. Most of you have my email address, or you can leave comments here…
So, what follows is my reply:
I'll start by saying both candidates are, in my opinion, very well qualified and will probably bring some good people in to work on these problems. Sen. Clinton is very smart and I think she would do a great job. I just like Obama better, I think he can do a better job of bringing people together, creating consensus, improving our standing in the world, etc. He's had to endure a lot of attacks and controversies in the past month from the media and his loose-cannon ex-pastor, but he's continued to keep his cool and keep pushing forward, and I think that's a good sign.
Clinton, in my opinion, is kind of an old-school Democratic who is not as likely to be innovative and not as likely to build consensus. I could be wrong. But that's how I see it.
Specifically on the questions you raised:
The energy question is not an area I'm an expert in. However, I do know Obama went to Detroit and told the automakers point-blank that they needed to make more efficient cars with higher mileage standards. I'm sure Clinton supports that in principle too. If we look at Bill Clinton's term, we see a President who was OK on the environment, did some good things as far as designating national parks, etc., but didn't really make the environment a top issue. He also didn't do anything too memorable in the area of energy policy. (At least not that I remember.)
I think the next president is going to have to make the environment and energy (the two are closely linked of course) a top priority. That means fighting some very powerful interests. I believe Obama is better positioned to do that. He makes the claim that he doesn't take money from lobbyists, which is true, with a caveat—he has taken individual contributions from people with who work for oil companies--as opposed to the firms that lobby for oil companies. But he is in general not as beholden to special interests as Clinton and McCain would be.
In the area of financial issues/home mortgage crisis, I think both candidates have good ideas on some possible solutions and would be a lot more proactive than the current administration, or McCain. The whole issue is an example of why free markets are not a panacea. People are losing their homes and their savings; it's not enough to stand back and "let the market work." Because sometimes it doesn't. My guess is that Obama, as a former community organizer, would have a much better feel for how these problems affect working people. But that's just a guess.
On the war in Iraq. Both Dem. Senators now oppose it, both are committed to bringing troops home as quickly as possible while still doing it in an orderly fashion, both say they want to emphasize diplomacy and minimize any upheaval caused by a US withdrawal. Both may be underplaying the difficulty of doing that. That war is a horrific mess, and anything we do to end our involvement is going to come with some very big risks. The only worse thing than doing something, though, is doing nothing and letting the anti-American hatred continue to fester there and in other parts of the Middle East. That's just my opinion, of course.
So both have pledged similar strategies. But they come from different backgrounds and will likely have different approaches overall in the foreign policy area. Clinton has shown herself to be a mainstream, maybe even slightly conservative Democrat when it comes to foreign policy. In my opinion, she has made a classic Clintonian calculation that voters see Dems as "weak" on military and foreign policy matters, so she has to appear more conservative to counter that. In a way, that's smart. And I don't think it's even as calculating as it sounds—many old-school Dems are pretty conservative when it comes to foreign policy. Bill Clinton's foreign policy was not really significantly different than that of previous administrations.
Obama, I believe, is charting a slightly different course, with a big emphasis on diplomacy and multi-lateral cooperation. I think we do need to improve our image overseas, and nothing would send a stronger signal that we are going to re-connect with the world than to elect an African American with a funny name. Now, some voters are not particularly interested in the idea that America has to get along with other countries; they prefer being the superpower and throwing our weight around. I don't think that's possible anymore, and it certainly hasn't worked out well for us in the past 7 years.
Who will do a better job of getting us out of Iraq? I don't know. I think Obama will do more to improve our image and bring other nations to the table to work on the problem, but can he be tough, I think is the question that skeptics will ask. Aside from the point that "being tough" may be part of our problem, I can't answer the question. We all have to take our own measure of the man.
I hope that helps. I believe either candidate is deserving of your vote.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)