I thought so.
Congratulations to eft, who almost precisely nailed the final percentage of the popular vote. Eft predicted a 53-47 final margin, the actual result was 52-46. None of us (eft, tall guy, moi) called the states/electoral counts exactly right, but I will take credit for thinking big in one of my two "final" predictions, which called it 375-163 for Obama. The final electoral count will probably be 364-174, if Missouri (Red), Georgia (Red), and North Carolina (Blue) end up the way they're leaning right now.
And who really thought Indiana would turn Blue???? (Blue Indiana, for one.)
I heard a lot of griping about the polls among McCain supporters, about how they are unreliable. McCain lost by 6 points, most polls were in a 4-8 point range (favoring Obama) at the end. No Bradley effect, and as in 2004, the final polls were pretty close to the final result. Rasmussen got it exactly right, and several others were very close.
The Democrats did not pick up the number of Senate and House seats that many predicted. This was not a "wave" election like 2006, although it clearly was a very good year for the D's. So we haven't suddenly become a nation of liberals. But the last two elections suggest we are not exactly a conservative country either.
Good, let's lose the labels and get something done.
Wednesday, November 05, 2008
Climbing the mountain
Got to bed about 1:30 am last night. I was hoping to hear a result on the Coleman/Franken race, but at that point Coleman was up about 80 votes (!!) and it was clear it wasn’t going to be called any time soon. So I went to bed.
Got up about 7 am thanks to our early-rising 2-year-old (and 7 am is really sleeping in for him.) And strangely, I didn’t feel too bad. Started cleaning up the party stuff while listening to NPR.
One thing that struck me about Obama’s speech last night was how somber and restrained it was. I loved the (subtle) references to Martin Luther King, Jr. and Sam Cooke. But overall, this speech was not a celebration. He obviously knows that all the work, all the fighting against stereotype and distrust and tribalism has just been prelude. Now he has to lead a nation.
I thought he did a masterful job of reaching out last night to all Americans. But there are some who heard it differently. A conservative woman I know told me today she is distraught because she heard Obama has said his first act will be to sign an executive order legalizing partial birth abortions. And that he has said he wants to redistrubute wealth.
I asked her if she thought his speech last night tried to extend a hand to people like her who didn’t support him. “No,” she said.
It’s an example of what President Obama will face. Rumors, myths, misinformation campaigns, and a segment of the electorate determined to see the worst in him, determined not to give him a break. No wonder he was somber last night. The hard work hasn’t yet begun.
Got up about 7 am thanks to our early-rising 2-year-old (and 7 am is really sleeping in for him.) And strangely, I didn’t feel too bad. Started cleaning up the party stuff while listening to NPR.
One thing that struck me about Obama’s speech last night was how somber and restrained it was. I loved the (subtle) references to Martin Luther King, Jr. and Sam Cooke. But overall, this speech was not a celebration. He obviously knows that all the work, all the fighting against stereotype and distrust and tribalism has just been prelude. Now he has to lead a nation.
I thought he did a masterful job of reaching out last night to all Americans. But there are some who heard it differently. A conservative woman I know told me today she is distraught because she heard Obama has said his first act will be to sign an executive order legalizing partial birth abortions. And that he has said he wants to redistrubute wealth.
I asked her if she thought his speech last night tried to extend a hand to people like her who didn’t support him. “No,” she said.
It’s an example of what President Obama will face. Rumors, myths, misinformation campaigns, and a segment of the electorate determined to see the worst in him, determined not to give him a break. No wonder he was somber last night. The hard work hasn’t yet begun.
Tuesday, November 04, 2008
Live Blogging from election night party 3
Things winding down here as the reality of President Obama sinks in.
I think we all need a little time to absorb this.
McCain's speech was dignified and gracious. We all commented on how we would've liked to see *this* John McCain run for President. But the reality was he had a tremendous uphill climb from the start. He stuck to what was tried and true in politics. In other years, against other opponents, it might've been enough.
But I think it's safe to say politics have changed. Along with the country.
And no matter what they tell you, change is good.
I think we all need a little time to absorb this.
McCain's speech was dignified and gracious. We all commented on how we would've liked to see *this* John McCain run for President. But the reality was he had a tremendous uphill climb from the start. He stuck to what was tried and true in politics. In other years, against other opponents, it might've been enough.
But I think it's safe to say politics have changed. Along with the country.
And no matter what they tell you, change is good.
Live Blogging from election night party 2
It's just before 9, and we've already had someone throw up. Of course, that someone was 7 months old. ("That's awfully young to be drinking," said one wag.) Things are looking very good for Obama, still too soon to call the Franken and Tinklenberg (of the Fightin' Tinklenbergs!!!) races.
Live Blogging from the election night party
7:40
About 30 peopl in our living room right now, not counting kids, and there are a few of them! A lot of buzz. I was pretty anxious earlier but feeling better now that two nets have called PA for Obama. I wish CNN would get on the ball. Early word is encouraging for Franken. Probably shouldn't jump to conclusions.
We bought a ton of food and beer. And everybody keeps bringing beer. A good problem to have.
About 30 peopl in our living room right now, not counting kids, and there are a few of them! A lot of buzz. I was pretty anxious earlier but feeling better now that two nets have called PA for Obama. I wish CNN would get on the ball. Early word is encouraging for Franken. Probably shouldn't jump to conclusions.
We bought a ton of food and beer. And everybody keeps bringing beer. A good problem to have.
I voted
A crisp autumn day in Minnesota. Clouds have moved in since but when I got to the community building next to our public park, the sun was still shining. Leaves were hitting the group with a crackling sound, toddlers were playing in the park. A dad with an "I voted" sticker sat and watched his kids.
I had been listening to Al Green on the way there: "Love and Happiness."
"Love can make you do right," Al sang.
There were no lines. I'd heard about long lines there at 7:30am but although the polling place seemed nearly full I didn't actually wait at all.
"Unh. Unh. Ahhh," Al sang.
The poll workers were helpful, and not as uniformly elderly as they have been in the past. One told me that as of 11:15 am they had seen more than 1,000 people vote. In the 2004 election, a total of 2,200 people voted at that location.
"Hey hey hey," Al sang.
I looked at the ballot. Filled out the ballot. Looked at it a moment more. We've been waiting a long time for this.
"Walk away with victory," Al sang.
I had been listening to Al Green on the way there: "Love and Happiness."
"Love can make you do right," Al sang.
There were no lines. I'd heard about long lines there at 7:30am but although the polling place seemed nearly full I didn't actually wait at all.
"Unh. Unh. Ahhh," Al sang.
The poll workers were helpful, and not as uniformly elderly as they have been in the past. One told me that as of 11:15 am they had seen more than 1,000 people vote. In the 2004 election, a total of 2,200 people voted at that location.
"Hey hey hey," Al sang.
I looked at the ballot. Filled out the ballot. Looked at it a moment more. We've been waiting a long time for this.
"Walk away with victory," Al sang.
Predictions!
Well, the call for predictions didn’t get overwhelming results but two hardy souls ventured their guesses. Sorry I didn’t get these up sooner, full comments can be found at the “Call for Predictions” post.
Eft predicted:
“Obama-53% McCain-47%.
AZ will go red bc nearly every state backs their own. (Except for TN and Gore in 2000.) CO will surprise the pollsters and go red bc they're more conservative than they like to admit. NV will go blue bc it's a state that doesn't mind taking a gamble and MT will join them just to rebel a bit. For the toss-ups: FL, MO, and IN will go red. (IN can't change, MO will be close, and FL will vote for the candidate closest to their average age.) ND, OH, and NC will go blue. (ND will align with the rest of the Upper Midwest, OH will glom along with PA, and NC will tip to Obama...barely.) The two hottest races in NC are for the governor and the US Senate. It seems it's all about change, so the governor will be McCrory (R) and the US Senator will be Hagen (D). McCrory will unseat the anointed one bc the present D administration is rife with scandal. Dole will be out of the Senate bc of her pandering to the conservative base-they want some changes too.”
Eft gives Franken a thumbs down on taking the Senate seat from Coleman.
The tall guy says:
“Obama 49% McCain 47% with 3% going to libertarians and greens. Electorial Obama gets about 300. Congress will increase with some more democrats in the house, I don't think they get to 60 in the senate, but close. Lieberman changes parties anyhow. Franken squeaks in. MN thinks they are not ready for him, but after a couple of years find out he's a better policy guy than they would have thought. He's not all red meat for the base as everyone believes, and all the old satire that is getting flung back at him is hard to bring back up 6 years later.”
I would agree that if Franken gets in he will probably be a pretty good Senator. Not sure he can do it though. I’m a fan and even I thought twice about voting for him.
Eft predicted:
“Obama-53% McCain-47%.
AZ will go red bc nearly every state backs their own. (Except for TN and Gore in 2000.) CO will surprise the pollsters and go red bc they're more conservative than they like to admit. NV will go blue bc it's a state that doesn't mind taking a gamble and MT will join them just to rebel a bit. For the toss-ups: FL, MO, and IN will go red. (IN can't change, MO will be close, and FL will vote for the candidate closest to their average age.) ND, OH, and NC will go blue. (ND will align with the rest of the Upper Midwest, OH will glom along with PA, and NC will tip to Obama...barely.) The two hottest races in NC are for the governor and the US Senate. It seems it's all about change, so the governor will be McCrory (R) and the US Senator will be Hagen (D). McCrory will unseat the anointed one bc the present D administration is rife with scandal. Dole will be out of the Senate bc of her pandering to the conservative base-they want some changes too.”
Eft gives Franken a thumbs down on taking the Senate seat from Coleman.
The tall guy says:
“Obama 49% McCain 47% with 3% going to libertarians and greens. Electorial Obama gets about 300. Congress will increase with some more democrats in the house, I don't think they get to 60 in the senate, but close. Lieberman changes parties anyhow. Franken squeaks in. MN thinks they are not ready for him, but after a couple of years find out he's a better policy guy than they would have thought. He's not all red meat for the base as everyone believes, and all the old satire that is getting flung back at him is hard to bring back up 6 years later.”
I would agree that if Franken gets in he will probably be a pretty good Senator. Not sure he can do it though. I’m a fan and even I thought twice about voting for him.
What are you seeing?
I'd be interested to know how things are looking to readers TWMDPB (TM). Long lines? Partisan displays? Did you get free coffee?
Election Day
Well, it's finally here.
Of the six daily tracking polls I'm looking at, only one has Obama under 50 percent. McCain's highest number is 46.
RCP has Obama leading in Ohio, Penn., Virginia, Florida, Colorado and Nevada. McCain leads in N. Carolina, Georgia, Indiana, and Missouri. Hard to believe that states like IN and GA are in play.
Polster.com's final poll average puts Obama at an 8 point lead, 52 - 44.
It's a beautiful day in Minnesota, warm and sunny. Big lines at the polls, I'm hearing. Win or lose, I love election days.
Of the six daily tracking polls I'm looking at, only one has Obama under 50 percent. McCain's highest number is 46.
RCP has Obama leading in Ohio, Penn., Virginia, Florida, Colorado and Nevada. McCain leads in N. Carolina, Georgia, Indiana, and Missouri. Hard to believe that states like IN and GA are in play.
Polster.com's final poll average puts Obama at an 8 point lead, 52 - 44.
It's a beautiful day in Minnesota, warm and sunny. Big lines at the polls, I'm hearing. Win or lose, I love election days.
Monday, November 03, 2008
Oh no...
I just realized that after tomorrow, there will be no polls to check every day. The thought kind of boggles my mind.
My Prediction
In preparing my Election Predictions, I scientifically assembled a vast array of numbers, statistics, data, and street-level observations, carefully analyzing all of it, in an attempt to come up with the definitive, fail-safe prediction for the outcome of the 2008 elections.
And then I decided to cheat.
The thin reed of hope that McCain supporters cling to is the fact that this really is a ground-breaking election. We’re in uncharted territory here. There could be a Bradley effect that makes the current polls completely inaccurate. Or, there could be a huge turnout of youth and first-time voters that swamps the polls and leads to an Obama landslide. The undecideds could break decisively for McCain (it would probably mean that 120 percent of the undecideds would have to break that way, but whatever…). Heck, let’s throw caution to the wind and say the IBD/TIPP poll numbers are based in reality…
In short, there are enough unknowns to keep this thing interesting right up to the end, even with Obama maintaining a significant lead in these last couple of weeks.
So I’ve prepared two scenarios. One has Obama winning by a strong margin.
The other is that Obama knocks this thing out of the park.
Scenario A:
A very conservative reading of the polls. I give Obama only the states where he is five points or more ahead, according to Pollster.com. In other words, he wins no tossup states. Chances of that are slim, but for the sake of argument…
What do we come up with:
Obama: 311 electoral votes
McCain: 227 electoral votes
In this scenario, I’ll throw out a 51 – 49 percent win for Obama nationally.
Scenario B:
Obama wins every state where he is currently ahead. I also throw in Indiana, Missouri and North Carolina for Obama. All those states are extremely close, and in this scenario, Obama’s ground game carries the day.
And the big map says:
Obama: 375 electoral votes
McCain 163 electoral votes
In this scenario, Obama wins 54—44. A ten point margin, one less than Gallup is showing today.
Now, believe me, I’ve tried to envision a scenario by which McCain wins. Just because I’m a gloom and doom kind of guy. But as far as I can see, the only way that McCain wins is if the polls are massively wrong. All of ‘em.
That just doesn’t seem possible, but we shall see.
As for other races, Cillizza of the WP predicts a Dem pickup of 30 seats in the house, and that sounds about right. Dems won’t get to 60 in the Senate, but they don’t really need to. There are a couple of moderate R’s left in the Senate, and they know their job security depends on them working in bipartisan way—including Minnesota’s Norm “finger in the wind” Coleman, who will probably win on Tuesday.
I’m pulling for El Tinklenberg (of the Fightin’ Tinklenbergs!!!) but I’ll call it for Bachmann. Hey, we need comic relief in our politicians from time to time, so Michele will serve well in that capacity.
I’ll post other predictions from the comments sometime tonight.
And then I decided to cheat.
The thin reed of hope that McCain supporters cling to is the fact that this really is a ground-breaking election. We’re in uncharted territory here. There could be a Bradley effect that makes the current polls completely inaccurate. Or, there could be a huge turnout of youth and first-time voters that swamps the polls and leads to an Obama landslide. The undecideds could break decisively for McCain (it would probably mean that 120 percent of the undecideds would have to break that way, but whatever…). Heck, let’s throw caution to the wind and say the IBD/TIPP poll numbers are based in reality…
In short, there are enough unknowns to keep this thing interesting right up to the end, even with Obama maintaining a significant lead in these last couple of weeks.
So I’ve prepared two scenarios. One has Obama winning by a strong margin.
The other is that Obama knocks this thing out of the park.
Scenario A:
A very conservative reading of the polls. I give Obama only the states where he is five points or more ahead, according to Pollster.com. In other words, he wins no tossup states. Chances of that are slim, but for the sake of argument…
What do we come up with:
Obama: 311 electoral votes
McCain: 227 electoral votes
In this scenario, I’ll throw out a 51 – 49 percent win for Obama nationally.
Scenario B:
Obama wins every state where he is currently ahead. I also throw in Indiana, Missouri and North Carolina for Obama. All those states are extremely close, and in this scenario, Obama’s ground game carries the day.
And the big map says:
Obama: 375 electoral votes
McCain 163 electoral votes
In this scenario, Obama wins 54—44. A ten point margin, one less than Gallup is showing today.
Now, believe me, I’ve tried to envision a scenario by which McCain wins. Just because I’m a gloom and doom kind of guy. But as far as I can see, the only way that McCain wins is if the polls are massively wrong. All of ‘em.
That just doesn’t seem possible, but we shall see.
As for other races, Cillizza of the WP predicts a Dem pickup of 30 seats in the house, and that sounds about right. Dems won’t get to 60 in the Senate, but they don’t really need to. There are a couple of moderate R’s left in the Senate, and they know their job security depends on them working in bipartisan way—including Minnesota’s Norm “finger in the wind” Coleman, who will probably win on Tuesday.
I’m pulling for El Tinklenberg (of the Fightin’ Tinklenbergs!!!) but I’ll call it for Bachmann. Hey, we need comic relief in our politicians from time to time, so Michele will serve well in that capacity.
I’ll post other predictions from the comments sometime tonight.
Sunday, November 02, 2008
Riding the Whirlwind
I don’t know about you, but I feel like I’m just hanging on as these last few days of The Most Important Election in The History of the Universe reaches its frenetic conclusion.
(It is an important election, of course. But you know, they do say that about every election.)
Today we got our first robocall. In most states, these are recorded phone calls that generally are attack ads aimed at a candidate. In MN, you can’t do robocalls as such, you have to have a live person making the call.
So guess what they do. They hire someone to call you and read a script. The young lady who called me read her script at an almost inhumanly fast pace, in a monotone, never pausing for even a beat, obviously not want to be interrupted or questioned. I actually could not make sense of the blizzard of words that were spilling over the phone line, but I did catch a few, “Obama” and “taxes” and “spread the wealth” and “McCain/Palin.” Maybe they are trying for a subliminal thing. I did get the impression that it was against Obama. The second the reader was done with her script, she hung up. Classy!
All I can say is, I hope the Republican National Committee is spending a lot of money on this stuff, because I can’t imagine a much less productive approach.
I will say that the R’s and the D’s are spending money like drunken plumbers in these last days. Our commerical breaks are about 60 percent political ads, some of them VERY ugly. The stuff they’re throwing up at Franken is as nasty as anything I’ve ever seen, and the stuff against Coleman is not subtle either. I really understand why some are saying “a pox on both your houses.”
I spent some time listening to AM radio yesterday as well, and I’m guessing the National Right to Life has a huge ad account because about every other ad was from them. They’re not Obama fans. They’re also lying through their teeth, in case you had any doubts.
So, where do we stand. There’s talk of tightening polls, but most of them actually look pretty stable. Obama leads by 4-9 points. I don’t know if he’ll pull off N. Carolina or Indiana or Missouri, but it’s notable that McCain and Palin are hitting eleven states, most of them which went to Bush in 2004.
I remember 2004. John Kerry made a similar last-minute, multi-state dash. Minnesota, Wisconsin and other blue states were among his last rallies. We won’t be seeing Obama in those states this time. This election is being fought out in red states.
(It is an important election, of course. But you know, they do say that about every election.)
Today we got our first robocall. In most states, these are recorded phone calls that generally are attack ads aimed at a candidate. In MN, you can’t do robocalls as such, you have to have a live person making the call.
So guess what they do. They hire someone to call you and read a script. The young lady who called me read her script at an almost inhumanly fast pace, in a monotone, never pausing for even a beat, obviously not want to be interrupted or questioned. I actually could not make sense of the blizzard of words that were spilling over the phone line, but I did catch a few, “Obama” and “taxes” and “spread the wealth” and “McCain/Palin.” Maybe they are trying for a subliminal thing. I did get the impression that it was against Obama. The second the reader was done with her script, she hung up. Classy!
All I can say is, I hope the Republican National Committee is spending a lot of money on this stuff, because I can’t imagine a much less productive approach.
I will say that the R’s and the D’s are spending money like drunken plumbers in these last days. Our commerical breaks are about 60 percent political ads, some of them VERY ugly. The stuff they’re throwing up at Franken is as nasty as anything I’ve ever seen, and the stuff against Coleman is not subtle either. I really understand why some are saying “a pox on both your houses.”
I spent some time listening to AM radio yesterday as well, and I’m guessing the National Right to Life has a huge ad account because about every other ad was from them. They’re not Obama fans. They’re also lying through their teeth, in case you had any doubts.
So, where do we stand. There’s talk of tightening polls, but most of them actually look pretty stable. Obama leads by 4-9 points. I don’t know if he’ll pull off N. Carolina or Indiana or Missouri, but it’s notable that McCain and Palin are hitting eleven states, most of them which went to Bush in 2004.
I remember 2004. John Kerry made a similar last-minute, multi-state dash. Minnesota, Wisconsin and other blue states were among his last rallies. We won’t be seeing Obama in those states this time. This election is being fought out in red states.
Friday, October 31, 2008
Call for Predictions!!
OK, I’m guessing that The World’s Most Dangerous Political Blog ™ , despite its dangerousness, is not pulling in thousands, or hundreds, or even dozens, of readers.
But for you proud few, here’s an opportunity to give your two cents.
I’m calling for Election Predictions. You can enter them into any comments at any time in the next few days, and I’ll compile them and put them on the main page. You should be able to comment anonymously, but give yourself some kind of moniker. Karl Rove, Joe the Plumber, Bob the Builder, anything.
What I’d like to see:
1) Your pick of who’s going win the Presidential election. Go into as much detail as you want. Predict the percentages. Call the states. Estimate the length of the concession/victory speech.
2) Your take on how the Senate/House races will turn out. How many seats with the Dems pick up? What are the big races in your state and how do you think they’ll turn out? And is America really ready for Senator Al Franken??
3) What else? Oh, we could discuss What It All Means. If the Dems have a big night, how will they govern? What’s next for the R party? And listen, I really expect my conservative readers to come through for me, allright? I want to hear—in detail!—about how the results prove that the Democratic Party is a fractured, dysfunctional mess that is on the verge of collapse. Don’t let me down, people.
So that’s it. Tell me what choice we’re going to make on Tuesday night. In as much or as little detail as you want.
I’ll post your thoughts, and mine, on Monday.
But for you proud few, here’s an opportunity to give your two cents.
I’m calling for Election Predictions. You can enter them into any comments at any time in the next few days, and I’ll compile them and put them on the main page. You should be able to comment anonymously, but give yourself some kind of moniker. Karl Rove, Joe the Plumber, Bob the Builder, anything.
What I’d like to see:
1) Your pick of who’s going win the Presidential election. Go into as much detail as you want. Predict the percentages. Call the states. Estimate the length of the concession/victory speech.
2) Your take on how the Senate/House races will turn out. How many seats with the Dems pick up? What are the big races in your state and how do you think they’ll turn out? And is America really ready for Senator Al Franken??
3) What else? Oh, we could discuss What It All Means. If the Dems have a big night, how will they govern? What’s next for the R party? And listen, I really expect my conservative readers to come through for me, allright? I want to hear—in detail!—about how the results prove that the Democratic Party is a fractured, dysfunctional mess that is on the verge of collapse. Don’t let me down, people.
So that’s it. Tell me what choice we’re going to make on Tuesday night. In as much or as little detail as you want.
I’ll post your thoughts, and mine, on Monday.
Obama is questioned – from the Left
This is a long video—11 minutes. However, I think it’s worth watching.
Overall, I think journalists should actually try to be fair and balanced, not advocates for a party or candidate. But if we do have to have political pundits and partisan talk show hosts—and it seems today’s cable industry is determined to give us those—it’s great to see someone with the charm, wit, and smarts of MSNBC's Rachel Maddow in a prominent time slot. After years of Hannity, O’Reilly, Beck, Scarborough, on and on and on, it’s really refreshing to see someone who’s not a white male conservative talking politics. (I know MSNBC also has Olbermann, whom I’m much less fond of, but who did break ground as a truly liberal perspective in the Center-Right world of cable news networks.)
And the discussion with Obama, on why he hasn’t been tougher on Republicans, is just terrific. It’s something that hasn’t been discussed much, how Obama’s restraint, discipline, and bipartisan message—his “slow and steady wins the race” strategy—has angered Dem. partisans at times but proven to be an effective and winning approach.
It’s a smart, wonkish, thoughtful discussion. No stereotypes, no gratuitous attacks, no clichés. Who told this guy he could compete in an American presidential election??
McCain’s fickle mind
I know that distorting your opponent’s views is a part of any campaign. Obama, for instance, has muddied the waters on McCain’s proposed tax of health care benefits, but that’s a very complicated subject with lots of room for interpretation.
But as we hit the last days of this long campaign, McCain's attacks against Obama have become inconsistent and incoherent. Look at what McCain said Wednesday on CNN about the “socialist” tag he’s been putting on Obama.
Larry King: You don't believe Barack Obama is a socialist do you?
McCain: "No, but I do believe that he has been in the far left of American politics and stated time after time that he believes in spreading the wealth around. He has talked about courts that redistribute the wealth. He has a record of voting against tax cuts. And for tax increases."
So after suggesting over and over again that Obama's a socialist, McCain, when asked directly, backpedals. And look at that next quote: “He has talked about courts that redistribute wealth.”
Yeah, he’s talked about how they don’t want to, and the context of his remarks is that he agrees it’s not a good idea for the courts to take on that role. So the bottom line is that Obama’s position is the opposite of what McCain is suggesting.
McCain also has a record of voting against tax cuts—he voted against Bush’s original tax cuts, the ones he now supports and wants to expand.
So: Obama’s a socialist, he’s not a socialist. Progressive income tax good, progressive income tax bad. Against big government, for big government bailouts of banks. Bush tax cuts bad, Bush tax cuts good.
This inability to get his story straight is just one of the reasons that McCain simply does not have a strong argument for taking control of our economic future.
But as we hit the last days of this long campaign, McCain's attacks against Obama have become inconsistent and incoherent. Look at what McCain said Wednesday on CNN about the “socialist” tag he’s been putting on Obama.
Larry King: You don't believe Barack Obama is a socialist do you?
McCain: "No, but I do believe that he has been in the far left of American politics and stated time after time that he believes in spreading the wealth around. He has talked about courts that redistribute the wealth. He has a record of voting against tax cuts. And for tax increases."
So after suggesting over and over again that Obama's a socialist, McCain, when asked directly, backpedals. And look at that next quote: “He has talked about courts that redistribute wealth.”
Yeah, he’s talked about how they don’t want to, and the context of his remarks is that he agrees it’s not a good idea for the courts to take on that role. So the bottom line is that Obama’s position is the opposite of what McCain is suggesting.
McCain also has a record of voting against tax cuts—he voted against Bush’s original tax cuts, the ones he now supports and wants to expand.
So: Obama’s a socialist, he’s not a socialist. Progressive income tax good, progressive income tax bad. Against big government, for big government bailouts of banks. Bush tax cuts bad, Bush tax cuts good.
This inability to get his story straight is just one of the reasons that McCain simply does not have a strong argument for taking control of our economic future.
Thursday, October 30, 2008
Joe jumps ship
Update: as it turns out, Joe showed up a later campaign stops. I guess there was just a mix-up. Kind of sums up this campaign, doesn't it?
Wednesday, October 29, 2008
Better to redistribute wealth to the wealthy, right?
I was talking recently with a conservative, and although we didn't agree on much, we did agree that cable news is incredibly annoying at times. There are a lot of "pundits" trying to fill time by talking about trivial stuff, or just endlessly blathering on about stuff that's been beaten to death already.
One of the few cable news pundits I really admire is David Gergen, who is always smart and even-handed. The following discussion does spend too much time on Sarah Palin's clothes -- but as they note, the McCain campaign keeps bringing it up-- but the really good stuff is toward the end, when Gergen notes that Reagan started a big wealth redistribution program, the earned income tax credit. I got a little cranky yesterday discussing McCain's "socialist" smears, but Gergen here does a pretty good job of calmly demolishing that completely dishonest line of attack.
(found at crooksandliars.com)
One of the few cable news pundits I really admire is David Gergen, who is always smart and even-handed. The following discussion does spend too much time on Sarah Palin's clothes -- but as they note, the McCain campaign keeps bringing it up-- but the really good stuff is toward the end, when Gergen notes that Reagan started a big wealth redistribution program, the earned income tax credit. I got a little cranky yesterday discussing McCain's "socialist" smears, but Gergen here does a pretty good job of calmly demolishing that completely dishonest line of attack.
(found at crooksandliars.com)
Tuesday, October 28, 2008
The latest smear: Socialist!!!
How mind-numbingly desperate has the McCain campaign become? They’ve found an interview from 7 years ago, in which Obama wades into some technical points of the Supreme Courts’ civil rights rulings, pulled out the term “redistribution of wealth,” completely out of context, and held up it, screaming “SOCIALIST!”
From what I can tell, and it is a very technical and academic discussion, Obama is saying that the Supreme Court didn’t want to get into the redistribution of wealth, but that other social forces, including community organizing, could bring about “redistributive change.”
Here’s the quote (taken from a conservative newsletter, but I believe it’s fairly accurate):
“But the Supreme Court never ventured into the issues of redistribution of the wealth and sort of more basic issues of political and economic justice in this society. And to that extent, as radical as I think people tried to characterize the Warren Court, it wasn’t that radical. It didn’t break us free from the essential constraints that were placed by the Founding Fathers in the Constitution … And the Warren Court interpreted, in the same way, that generally the Constitution is a charter of negative liberties … I think there was a tendency to lose track of the political and community organizing activities on the ground that are able to put together the actual coalitions of power through which you bring about redistributive change.”
In other words, African Americans, traditionally among the poorest and least powerful in our society, could grab a bigger piece of the pie by organizing themselves and gaining more political power.
WHAT A RADICAL STATEMENT! OH MY GOD, IT”S LIKE HE’S JOSEPH STALIN OR GROUCHO MARX OR SOMETHING!!
How stupid do you have to be to fall for this stuff? What is wrong with people that they are so quick to jump to totally unjustified conclusions based on such thin evidence?
Let’s put it another way: Yes, Obama wants to “redistribute wealth.” He wants to change our tax policies that have been favoring the extremely wealthy and make them more favorable to the middle class.
That's socialist?
Lots of presidents have changed tax policy; raising taxes for some, lowering them for others. These include Ronald Reagan, George H.W. Bush, and Bill Clinton. This was also redistribution of wealth. None of these folks were called socialists by anybody with a brain.
McCain supporters have said a lot of less-than-honest things. But this descent into caveman-like stupidity is really hard to watch.
Sorry to rant; I guess the long election season is finally getting to me.
Here’s a WP fact-checker comment on this.
Here’s a very good analysis of the "Obama is a socialist" claim,by Politifact.com.
From what I can tell, and it is a very technical and academic discussion, Obama is saying that the Supreme Court didn’t want to get into the redistribution of wealth, but that other social forces, including community organizing, could bring about “redistributive change.”
Here’s the quote (taken from a conservative newsletter, but I believe it’s fairly accurate):
“But the Supreme Court never ventured into the issues of redistribution of the wealth and sort of more basic issues of political and economic justice in this society. And to that extent, as radical as I think people tried to characterize the Warren Court, it wasn’t that radical. It didn’t break us free from the essential constraints that were placed by the Founding Fathers in the Constitution … And the Warren Court interpreted, in the same way, that generally the Constitution is a charter of negative liberties … I think there was a tendency to lose track of the political and community organizing activities on the ground that are able to put together the actual coalitions of power through which you bring about redistributive change.”
In other words, African Americans, traditionally among the poorest and least powerful in our society, could grab a bigger piece of the pie by organizing themselves and gaining more political power.
WHAT A RADICAL STATEMENT! OH MY GOD, IT”S LIKE HE’S JOSEPH STALIN OR GROUCHO MARX OR SOMETHING!!
How stupid do you have to be to fall for this stuff? What is wrong with people that they are so quick to jump to totally unjustified conclusions based on such thin evidence?
Let’s put it another way: Yes, Obama wants to “redistribute wealth.” He wants to change our tax policies that have been favoring the extremely wealthy and make them more favorable to the middle class.
That's socialist?
Lots of presidents have changed tax policy; raising taxes for some, lowering them for others. These include Ronald Reagan, George H.W. Bush, and Bill Clinton. This was also redistribution of wealth. None of these folks were called socialists by anybody with a brain.
McCain supporters have said a lot of less-than-honest things. But this descent into caveman-like stupidity is really hard to watch.
Sorry to rant; I guess the long election season is finally getting to me.
Here’s a WP fact-checker comment on this.
Here’s a very good analysis of the "Obama is a socialist" claim,by Politifact.com.
Monday, October 27, 2008
... Said the man who made the mountain...
"Former White House adviser Karl Rove, credited with winning two elections for President Bush, on Sunday said GOP nominee John McCain has a “very steep hill to climb” in his quest for the presidency.
Rove, who often puts a positive spin on things for the GOP, on “Fox News Sunday” offered a bleaker assessment of the state of the race from a Republican point of view. In his own electoral map, Rove has Democratic nominee Barack Obama ahead with 317 electoral votes after moving Ohio, Indiana, Colorado and Virginia to the Illinois senator’s column."
-- from The Hill
I love the understatement about Karl "I have the real math" Rove. Yes, on occasion he has been known to spin things...
Rove, who often puts a positive spin on things for the GOP, on “Fox News Sunday” offered a bleaker assessment of the state of the race from a Republican point of view. In his own electoral map, Rove has Democratic nominee Barack Obama ahead with 317 electoral votes after moving Ohio, Indiana, Colorado and Virginia to the Illinois senator’s column."
-- from The Hill
I love the understatement about Karl "I have the real math" Rove. Yes, on occasion he has been known to spin things...
Friday, October 24, 2008
All the News from Lake Tinklenberg
Michele Bachmann (apologies for the misspelling in earlier posts) continues to be big news, garnering a video entry at Talking Points Memo. Quite entertaining. By the way, a new poll puts Elwyn Tinklenberg (of the Fightin' Tinklenbergs!!!) up 47 to 44 over Bachmann. A new poll is due out today. I still have my doubts, but go El!!
In other Minnesota news: Hilllary Clinton appeared with Al Franken recently and a new TV ad features her talking up Franken. A bunch of Minnesota politicians (Coleman, Klobuchar, Bachmann, Ellison) had their homes vandalized by spray-pointed graffiti that featured nasty words and reference to Psalm 2. Huh? Former Repub. Gov. Arne Carlson endorsed Obama, who is way ahead in the latest MN polls (yawn).
In other Minnesota news: Hilllary Clinton appeared with Al Franken recently and a new TV ad features her talking up Franken. A bunch of Minnesota politicians (Coleman, Klobuchar, Bachmann, Ellison) had their homes vandalized by spray-pointed graffiti that featured nasty words and reference to Psalm 2. Huh? Former Repub. Gov. Arne Carlson endorsed Obama, who is way ahead in the latest MN polls (yawn).
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)